Recent laws, such as the one in Massachusetts, prohibit employers from asking job applicants about their previous salary. HR professionals have adjusted their approach by asking applicants what salary they expect to make instead. This new approach is expected to result in employees aiming for the highest possible salary that they would accept, while also communicating their outside options. Employees who believe their past earnings are higher than average may choose to disclose that information as a way of signaling their credibility and negotiability. By asking about future salary expectations instead of past salaries, the aim of these laws is to address the pay gap, particularly for women who have stepped out of the labor market. The hope is that women will have enough information to ask for salaries that correct for their previous lower salaries. However, it is important to note that employers can still infer the gender of the employee and make inferences based on this information. The overall impact and effectiveness of these laws are still uncertain and require further study.
One of the primary reasons we work is to earn money, but many of us feel uncomfortable telling others how much we make. This fear may be working against women, because research has shown that salary transparency can help narrow the gender pay gap.
With the help of experts, we explore the complexities of talking about our salaries. First, an economist walks through the pros and cons of disclosing your pay. Then, the host of a personal finance podcast explains why she encourages people to speak openly about salaries. Finally, an HR executive gives advice on how to deal with the gut punch of learning that a peer makes more than you do.
Our HBR reading list:
Sign up to get the Women at Work monthly newsletter.
Email us: womenatwork@hbr.org
Our theme music is Matt Hill’s “City In Motion,” provided by Audio Network.