

Restitutio
Sean P Finnegan
Restitutio is a Christian theology podcast designed to get you thinking about biblical theology, church history, and apologetics in an effort to recover the original Christian faith of Jesus and the apostles apart from all of the later traditions that settled on it like so much sediment, obscuring and mutating primitive Christianity into dogma and ritual. Pastor Sean Finnegan, the host of Restitutio, holds to a Berean approach to truth: that everyone should have an open mind, but check everything against the bible to see how it measures up. If you are looking for biblical unitarian resources, information about the kingdom of God, or teachings about conditional immortality, Restitutio is the Christian podcast for you!
Episodes
Mentioned books

Feb 4, 2018 • 53min
131 Love without Limits (Victor Gluckin)
How do you deal with difficult people? Jesus teaches us that there’s nothing noteworthy about showing love to those who love us. Rather, he says we are to be like God who sends rain on the just and the wicked. He calls us to love annoying people, boring people, monopolizing people, vengeful people, shallow people, prideful people, and all other kinds of difficult people. We are not free to set our own artificial boundary on love, instead we must love without limits. Listen to this powerful message by Victor Gluckin, originally taught at Revive 2018. This sermon will challenge you to strengthen your relationship with God since he alone can sustain you with his love so you can freely love those who don’t love you back.
—— Links ——
Listen to all the other messages from Revive 2018
Find out more about pastor Victor Gluckin at his church website or follow him on Twitter
Browse other Restitutio episodes with Victor Gluckin
115 Don’t Put It on a Cart
79 Proud of Our God
66: What I’ve Been Saved From
24: Now Is Our Time To Speak
Intro music: “District Four” by Kevin MacLeod. Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License.

Feb 2, 2018 • 47min
130 Missionaries, Adventists, and Mormons (Five Hundred 14)
The 1800s was an exciting time for Christianity in America. At the same time that secularism and liberal Christianity made huge gains, several renewal movements occurred throughout the land, including the Second Great Awakening. In this episode you learn about the birth of the Protestant missionary movement with the Moravians and the Baptists, how the various Adventist denominations got their start, and last of all the most successful made-in-America religion–Mormonism. These thumbnail sketches will help you understand a number of groups that are still around today.
This is lecture 14 of a history of Christianity class called Five Hundred: From Martin Luther to Joel Osteen.
All the notes are available here as a pdf.
—— Notes ——
Pietism (late 17th c. to 20th c.)
Movement within Reformed and Lutheran countries (happened during Enlightenment)
1675 – Philipp Jakob Spener (1635-1705) published Pious Desires
The earnest and thorough study of the Bible in private meetings
Laity should share in the spiritual government of the Church
Knowledge of Christianity must be attended by the practice
A sympathetic and kindly treatment of Christians of other groups
Universities should give more prominence to the devotional life
Rather than pleasing rhetoric, preach to implant Christianity in the inner man
Emphasized inner life and conversion
Millennialism (Pietists had millennialist leanings)
Continued baptizing infants but de-emphasized it in favor of conversion experience
Halle in Saxony established as center of Pietism
Moravians (Unitas Fratrum)
Descendants of the 15th Hussites; persecuted during 30 years war in Bohemia
In late 17th c., they went to Poland; 18th c. they went to Saxony
1722 – Count Nikolaus Ludwig von Zinzendorf (1700-1760), a Pietist who attended school at Halle (godson to Spener) gave the Moravians land which became the community of Herrnhut
1731 – Some Moravians went to the coronation of the King of Denmark.
1732 – Johann Leonhard Dober (1706-1766) chose David Nitschmann (1695-1772) as his travelling companion; petitioned the Danish government for passage to St. Thomas in Virgin Islands
Teaching them about God and how to read and write
In less than a century, the Pietist Moravians sent 300 missionaries throughout the world and baptized some 3,000 converts.
Moravian motto:
“In essentials, unity; in nonessentials, liberty; and in all things, love”
Today, around 825,000 members worldwide (largest concentration is in Tanzania)
Modern Missions
1792 – William Carey (1761-1834) published An Enquiry into the Obligations of Christians to Use Means for the Conversion of the Heathens
Used the best available geographic and ethnographic data to map and count the number of people who had never heard the gospel
“It is inconsistent for ministers to please themselves with thoughts of a numerous auditory, cordial friends, a civilized country, legal protection, affluence, splendor, or even a competency. The flights, and hatred of men, and even pretended friends, gloomy prisons, and tortures, the society of barbarians of uncouth speech, miserable accommodations in wretched wildernesses, hunger, and thirst, nakedness, weariness, and painfulness, hard work, and but little worldly encouragement should rather be the objects of their expectation. Thus the apostles act

Jan 28, 2018 • 39min
Off Script 41: Guns, Immigrants, and White Evangelicals
This is part two of our discussion about Charles Mathewes’ Washington Post article, “White Christianity is in big trouble. And it’s its own biggest threat.” Check out part one here. In this episode we consider gun control, immigration, the death penalty, and treatment of the poor in an effort to understand and respond to evangelicalism’s ongoing public relations problem. Are “white evangelicals” as Mathewes puts it “a breathtakingly cruel bunch?”
—— Links ——
Read the original Washington Post article here
Listen to part one of this discussion: Off Script 40: Roy Moore, Gay Wedding Cakes, and White Evangelicals
Check out these Off Script episodes mentioned in this discussion:
Off Script 38: Killing in War (A Christian View of Violence)
Off Script 28: Seeking a Christian View on Refugees and Immigrants
Off Script 37: Killing Criminals (A Christian View of Capital Punishment)
Off Script 16: Christians Discussing Politics
Intro music: “Protofunk” by Kevin MacLeod. Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License.

Jan 26, 2018 • 55min
129 Losing Faith (Five Hundred 13)
This lecture covers the two main types of criticisms leveled against Christianity during the Enlightenment period: biblical and philosophical. In addition you’ll see how some Christians dug their heals in and worked hard to defend their faith while others gave ground but reinterpreted Christianity in a way that would not only survive the criticisms but also attract “cultured despisers.” We’ll conclude with a brief sketch of unitarianism in America.
This is lecture 13 of a history of Christianity class called Five Hundred: From Martin Luther to Joel Osteen.
All the notes are available here as a pdf.
—— Notes ——
Early Views of Biblical Inspiration
“The Holy Spirit did not simply inspire the meaning or sense of the words contained in Scripture, which the prophets and apostles then set forth, expressed, and embellished with their own words by their own will. The Holy Spirit supplied, inspired, and dictated the very words and each and every utterance to the writers.” –Johann Quenstedt (1623-1687)[1]
“The Hebrew Original of the Old Testament…is, not only in its consonants, but in its vowels—ether the vowel points themselves, or at least the power of the points—not only in its matter, but in its words, inspired of God” –Helvetic Consensus (1675)[2]
In the 18th c., we have Deism and Pietism.
In the 19th c., we have higher criticism and revivalism.
In the 20th c., we have secularism and Pentecostalism.
Enlightenment[3] (1650-1890)
Not an organized movement but widespread current of thought
Critical of superstition, enthusiasm, fanaticism, and supernaturalism
Philosophy is no longer the handmaiden of theology but an independent field
Though in France the Enlightenment was anti-Christian, it was embraced by Christians in other places like England and Germany
Three phases (according to Alister McGrath)
Demonstrating the rational nature of Christian belief (John Locke’s The Reasonableness of Christianity)
Could derive Christian beliefs from reason alone
Reason sits in judgment over revelation
1751 French Encyclopédie: multi-volumes covering all human knowledge and written by atheist Denis Diderot (1713-1784) and the Philosophes
Deism (17th-18th centuries)
Revelation, ritual, and traditional practices minimized or written off as superstitious
Clergy criticized for
Keeping people in bondage
Monopolizing truth using their authority
Freedom to inquire and religious toleration
Essence of religion is morality expressed in universal principles
Idea that all religions contained the same basic moral precepts
1738: Pope Clement XII denounced Deism
Thomas Jefferson (1743-1826)
Cut miracles out of the gospels[4]
Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790)
Philosophical Criticisms of Christianity
1656 – Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677) excommunicated from Talmud Torah congregation
1777 – Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion by David Hume (1711-1778)
Only have knowledge of what we directly experience (empiricist)
Cannot determine cause from effect (the world does not point to a creator)
Miracles were made up, based on hearsay, or the result of ignora

Jan 21, 2018 • 48min
Off Script 40: Roy Moore, Gay Wedding Cakes, and White Evangelicals
While scrolling through Facebook, I came across Charles Mathewes’ Washington Post article, “White Christianity is in big trouble. And it’s its own biggest threat.” At first reading, I was infuriated at what I felt were unfair criticisms, but after I thought about it, I realized what an opportunity this article presented. It collects together no less than thirteen criticisms against Christianity. In this episode Dan Fitzsimmons, Rose Rider, and I (Sean Finnegan) respond to the first seven, including:
Our society’s war on Christmas bothers Christians
A Christian baker refused to sell a cake for a gay wedding
80% of white evangelicals in Alabama voted for a pedophile
We’re ignorant of history
We’re ignorant of the current state of the world
We’re ignorant about scientific knowledge
We’re surprisingly ignorant about our own religion
—— Links ——
Read the original Washington Post article here
Intro music: “Protofunk” by Kevin MacLeod. Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License.

Jan 19, 2018 • 48min
128 Colonials and Methodists (Five Hundred 12)
Hear the winding tale of early Christian history in the Americas with a special focus on the thirteen colonies. Right from the start the Americas were full of Christian diversity including Catholicism, the Church of England, Puritans, Baptists, and Quakers. In this lecture you’ll see how this diversity led to an unprecedented level of religious tolerance and flourishing. Other significant issues in this period include the horrors of the slave trade and the treatment of native Americans as well as the impressive success of the Great Awakening under the preaching of George Whitefield and Jonathan Edwards.
This is lecture 12 of a history of Christianity class called Five Hundred: From Martin Luther to Joel Osteen.
All the notes are available here as a pdf.
—— Notes ——
Founding the Colonies
Catholicism in the Americas
Spanish claims included American west coast, Florida, and much territory in central and South America (Catholic)
French claims included eastern Canada (Quebec) and the territory of Louisiana (Catholic)
1634 Catholics founded “Mary land”
1607 Virginia founded as first English Colony
founded as joint effort by the Virginia Company to make money (Tobacco export)
brought Church of England to New World
Separatists founded New England
1620 Plymouth settled (from Brownists who were sojourning in Holland)
1630 Puritans establish Massachusetts Bay Colony fleeing from Archbishop Laud
1648 Cambridge Platform: Westminster Confession w/ congregational polity
No religious freedom
1636 Harvard founded for training of Puritan ministers
1631 Roger Williams (1603?-1683) arrived
1639 Williams founds first Baptist church in RI
1681 William Penn founded Pennsylvania (Penn’s Forrest)
he was a Quaker who tolerated all monotheists
many people outside of England moved to Pennsylvania including Moravians, Lutherans, German Reformed, Amish
Immorality
tobacco
1602 an English doctor wrote Chimney-Sweepers or a Warning for Tabacconists warning about health risks
1604 King James wrote a tract against tobacco
1617 Virginia exported 10 tons; 1622 30 tons; 1627 250 tons; 1639 1,500 tons; 1688 colonies exported 14,000 tons; 1771 52,000 tons
rum
1667 Boston’s first distillery
1774 Mass had 63 distilleries, producing 2.7 million gallons of rum a year
RI had more than 30 distilleries
colonists preferred rum made in the West Indies so they sold it in Africa and to Indians
Golden Triangle
molasses bought in New England to make rum
rum sold in Africa to purchase slaves
slaves sold in West Indies to purchase molasses
slavery
1619 first Africans came to VA as indentured servants (work for a set time to pay off travel debt)
by 1680 racial slavery
insanely inhumane conditions on slave trader ships
Falconhridge: “The hardships and inconveniences suffered by the Negroes during the passage are scarcely to be enumerated or conceived. They are far more violently affected by seasickness than the Europeans. It frequently terminates in death, especially among the women.The exclusion of fresh air is among the most intolerable. Most ships have portholes for air. But whenever the sea is rough and the rain heavy, it becomes necessary to shut these and every other conveyance by which air is admitted. The fresh air being thus excluded, the Negroes’ quarters very s

Jan 14, 2018 • 44min
Off Script 39: Sexual Harassment, A Christian Response
Several significant sexual harassment cases have come to light in the last few months. Now a whole range of behaviors have come under scrutiny as women (and some men) have felt emboldened to make public their experiences. In this episode we even out our Off Script panel with one more female voice, Terri Crowder, to help us discuss this prevalent phenomenon from street corners to workplaces to churches. After discussing sexual harassment in some detail, we bring relevant scriptures to light to provide a Christian response.
—— Links ——
More on the Christian work ethic here
Also check out Off Script 31: Stewarding Our Bodies
Check out the first part of episode 603 of This American Life to hear what happens when a woman confronts men after catcalling her.
Intro music: “Protofunk” by Kevin MacLeod. Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License.

Jan 12, 2018 • 47min
127 Catholicism (Five Hundred 11)
Although the focus of this class is on the history of Protestants of various stripes, it’s also important to realize that Catholicism changed a good deal during the last five hundred years. In this lecture, you’ll get a brief sketch of the history of significant Catholic movements and doctrinal declarations during this period, including the inquisition, Council of Trent, the Jesuits, doctrines about Mary, the first and second Vatican Councils, and much more.
This is lecture 11 of a history of Christianity class called Five Hundred: From Martin Luther to Joel Osteen.
All the notes are available here as a pdf.
—— Notes ——
Initial Responses to Reformation
Pope Leo X thought Reformation was just a drunken brawl among German monks
1541 Regensburg Colloquy
Inquisition
started in 12th France to combat heresy of Cathars and Waldensians
The 1578 handbook for inquisitors spelled out the purpose of inquisitorial penalties:”… for punishment does not take place primarily and per se for the correction and good of the person punished, but for the public good in order that others may become terrified and weaned away from the evils they would commit.”
1821 Inquisition abolished in Portugal; 1834 Inquisition outlawed in Spain
1908 Inquisition renamed to The Sacred Congregation of the Holy Office
1965 Inquisition renamed to The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF)
Council of Trent (1545-1563)
response to Protestant movement
Catholicism after Trent is called Tridentine Catholicism
7 sacraments, recognized Apocrypha as canon, Scripture and Tradition determine doctrine
bishop as pastor of diocese rather than prince of the church: have to live in their diocese, preach regularly, inspect clergy to insure proper teaching, meet regularly at synods
support of Baroque style of art, music, and architecture
1559 Index of Prohibited Books
list had circulated since 1521 in Paris and Louvain
1966 Index of Prohibited Books abolished
still to this day the word Imprimatur (let it be printed) is on approved Catholic books
2011 imprimatur first applied to iPhone app
Jesuits (Society of Jesus)
Ignatius of Loyola (1491-1556)
1521 severely wounded by a cannon ball
1522 stayed in a cave for a while practicing severe asceticism
1523 pilgrimage to the holy land
1524 finished Spiritual Exercises (Ignatian Contemplation)
returned to Spain and preached on street corners
1528 attended University of Paris and got master’s degree
1534 started Jesuits with 6 companions, taking solemn vows
1540 Society of Jesus approved by pope
Rules of the Order: vows of poverty, chastity, obedience to pope, go anywhere in the world
Rule 13 “That we may be altogether of the same mind and in conformity … if [the Church] shall have defined anything to be black which to our eyes appears to be white, we ought in like manner to pronounce it to be black.”
Missionary Activity
Francis Xavier (1506-1552) preached in India and had success in Japan
Matteo Ricci (1522-1610) dressed as Confusion scholar, brought Christianity to China
Robert Nobili (1577-1656) brought Christianity to Brahman caste in India
Alexander de Rhodes (1591-1660) preached in Vietnam
Colonialism

Jan 5, 2018 • 49min
126 Dissidents in Britain (Five Hundred 10)
Learn about the dissident groups in Britain in the 17th and 18th centuries, including the Puritans, Baptists, Quakers, and Unitarians. In addition, Sean Kelly presents a vignette of John Biddle’s life and influence.
This is lecture 10 of a history of Christianity class called Five Hundred: From Martin Luther to Joel Osteen.
All the notes are available here as a pdf.
—— Notes ——
Puritans
Robert Browne (1550-1633)
Treatise of Reformation without Tarrying for Any, and of the Wickedness of those Preachers which will not Reform…till the Magistrate Command and Compel Them
Reformation needed to take place whether or not the king wanted it or not
Congressionalist rather than Presbyterian
A group of Dutch Brownists were the ones who came to the New World in 1620s
English Baptists
Not related to continental Anabaptists
Founded by John Smyth in 1609, an Englishman from Cambridge who fled to Amsterdam
General [Arminian] vs. Particular [Calvinist] are two types of Baptists
Reject role of the state in matters of conscience (church should be independent of the state)
John Bunyan (1628-88), Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners (1666)
Wrote autobiography Grace Abounding to Chief of Sinners
Pilgrim’s Progress (1678), second part appeared in 1684
Roger Williams (1603?-1683) brought Baptist faith to America
Quakers (“Society of Friends”)
Founded by George Fox (1624-1691)
“Inner Light” written in 1647: The word of God is not confined to the Bible but rather came directly to each person (inner light or inner voice)
He rejected social distinctions, allowed women to preach
Pacifists and egalitarians (worked against slavery in the US using underground railway)
No sacraments at all b/c they were physical
Total silence during meetings until someone is inspired to speak
British Unitarians
John Biddle (1615-1662), the father of English Unitarianism
brilliant man
1634 his anthology he published his translations from classics into English
at university he “outran his instructors and became tutor to himself” (Protesters, 131)
1634 he went to Magdalen Hall at Oxford
1641 he was headmaster of the Crypt Grammar School in Gloucester
immersed himself in Scripture for years
knew entire NT by heart in English and most in Greek, though about Rev. 4 his memory got fuzzy
claimed he never read Socinian literature before coming to his own opinions
wrote a pamphlet, Twelve Arguments against the Deity of the Holy Spirit
1646 summoned to London’s parliament and imprisoned for 5 years
1648 Publishes two anti-Trinitarian documents
A Confession of Faith Toughing the Holy Trinity According to Scripture
The Testimonies of Irenaeus, Justin Martyr, Tertullian, Novatianus, Theophilus, Origen. As Also of Arnobius, Lactanius, Easebius, Hilary and Brightman Concerning the One God and the Persons of the Holy Trinity
1652 Biddle released and remained in London where he found fellowship
1654 Biddle published his Twofold Catechism
when Oliver Cromwell got in power Biddle was released
returned to quiet active work in a church
two months later he was imprisoned in Newgate prison
remained at St Mary’s for 3 years

Dec 28, 2017 • 55min
125 The Reformation in Britain (Five Hundred 9)
In this sprint through British church history, you’ll learn about King Henry VIII and his staggering Act of Supremacy when he pulled the Church of England out of Catholicism and appointed himself the head of the church. After Henry’s death, England swayed back and forth as Henry’s successors adopted Protestantism then Catholicism then Protestantism again. Still none of this tumult compares to the chaos of the English Civil War a century later when a Protestant Parliament executed a too Catholic King Charles I for treason and initiated stringent Puritanical laws throughout the land. You’ll also learn about the persistent and tenacious John Knox who was instrumental in bringing the Reformation to Scotland.
This is lecture 9 of a history of Christianity class called Five Hundred: From Martin Luther to Joel Osteen.
All the notes are available here as a pdf.
—— Notes ——
Henry VIII (1491-1547)
Wives, Heirs
Catherine of Aragon (m. 1503), mother of Mary Tudor
The Great Issue: could not divorce her to marry mistress Ann Bolin
1534: Act of Supremacy (Henry declared “Supreme Head” of the church
Ann Bolin (m. 1533), mother of Elizabeth
Jane Seymour (m. 1536), mother of Edward
Anne of Cleves (m. 1540)
Catherine Howard (m. 1540)
Catherine Parr (m. 1543)
Religious Policies
Ostensibly Catholic, apart from his great issue (Cardinal Wolsey)
Dissolution of monasteries and shrines
200 hangings of people who resisted Henry’s royal assertions as head of the church
Six Articles (1539) affirmed traditional Catholic understandings of
Transubstantiation, no cup for laity during communion, chastity for clergy, private Masses, confession
William Tyndale (1495-1536)
Languages: Greek, Latin, French, German, Spanish, Italian, English
1521 – ordained a Catholic priest
1522 – he was called before John Bell—chancellor of the diocese of Worcester but was released
“We were better to be without God’s laws than the pope’s.” Master Tyndale, hearing this, full of godly zeal and not bearing that blasphemous saying, replied, “I defy the pope, and all his laws;” and added, “If God spared my life, ere many years I will cause a boy that driveth the plough to know more of the Scripture than thou doest.”
1523 – he went to Bishop Cuthbert Tunstall to ask permission to translate the Scriptures
1524 – he fled England to the continent possibly to study at Wittenberg (12 years a fugitive)
1525 – he finished the NT
1526 – the NT was printed in Worms and Antwerp
1526 – Tunstall had as many copies as he could find publicly burned
1529 – Cardinal Wolsey condemned Tyndale as a heretic
1530 – he finished the Torah (Gen-Deut)
1530 – he wrote The Practice of the Prelates, opposing Henry VIII’s divorce as unscriptural
1531 – he finished Jonah
1534 – a new edition of the NT published (thoroughly revised)
1535 – Henry Philips gained Tyndale’s trust and friendship and betrayed him to the authorities.
Letter from Tyndale to overseer of the castle in September: “I believe, most excellent Sir, that you are not unacquainted with the decision reached concerning me. On which account, I beseech your lordship, even by the Lord Jesus, that if I am to pass the winter here, to urge upon the lord commissary, if he will deign, to send me from


