Minnesota's Most Notorious: Where Blood Runs Cold

In this captivating discussion, Penny A. Petersen, author of *Minneapolis Madams: The Lost History of Prostitution on the Riverfront*, unearths the hidden stories of Minneapolis's past. She reveals the regulated prostitution system thriving along the riverfront and the complexities faced by madams like Nettie Conley. Petersen highlights how economic survival compelled women into the trade, while also offering a nuanced look at class dynamics within brothels. The conversation explores the transformative impact of societal changes on these women's lives and the legacy they left behind.

Explore a compilation of bizarre, criminal, and amusing stories reported by the Minneapolis Tribune on August 4th, 1913. Topics include car thefts, mistaken identities, arrests, entertaining musical performances, a musician's guitar causing chaos during a diagnosis, a mysterious murder in Minneapolis, tragic incidents, and a fabricated hold-up story unraveled by police chief in 1913.

The podcast discusses the Younger brothers' first taste of freedom after 25 years in prison, exploring their wonder and adjustment to the outside world. It highlights their experiences in town, interactions with the warden, job offers for Cole, and an emotional goodbye as Jim gives away his canary bird.

Gibson Stanton, site manager of the Warden's House Museum, discusses Minnesota's first prison and infamous inmates, the Younger brothers. She shares intriguing theories about their post-incarceration lives, including Cole's mysterious death and Jim's suspicious suicide. The podcast delves into historical prison escapes, corrupt practices, and explores the museum's exhibits offering a glimpse into the inmates' experiences.

In this engaging discussion, guest Gary Brueggemann, an author and historian, unpacks the chilling murder of Sergeant John Hayes and the dubious character of his partner, Edward Phalen, who may have been the killer. He dives into the complex relationships and conflicting evidence surrounding the case, revealing the historical challenges in documentation. Shifting gears, Brueggemann also tackles the controversy around renaming Lake Calhoun, urging listeners to consider the nuanced legacies of historical figures in today’s society.

Gary Brueggemann, a teacher and historian, dives into the thrilling origins of St. Paul, Minnesota. He uncovers the chilling tale of John Hayes' murder and how it entangled Edward Phalen as a prime suspect. The podcast also shines a light on the infamous river pirate Pierre 'Pig's Eye' Parrant, revealing his significant role in the city's early days. Brueggemann shares his passion for Minnesota history and the investigative journey that unearthed the complexities of this dark past, blending mystery with historical insight.

In this engaging discussion, journalist Tim Mahoney dives into the murky depths of organized crime in 1920s and 30s Saint Paul, focusing on the infamous Barker-Karpis gang and their associate, Big Tom Brown. He reveals the shady alliances between mobsters, corrupt law enforcement, and local breweries. Mahoney also unpacks the audacious staged kidnappings and grave outcomes for infamous criminals. The evolution from bootlegging to bold bank heists illustrates a treacherous world where crime thrived amidst chaos.

In this insightful discussion, Betty Gove, an author and poet with a personal link to the case, delves into the heartbreaking murder of Josefina Olson in 1902. She recounts the tragic circumstances surrounding the young woman's death at the hands of her father, just before her wedding. Through rich storytelling, Betty shares her family's emotional journey and how these events shaped their identity. The conversation also touches on childhood memories of trauma and explores the lingering effects of tragedy across generations.

Susi and Todd Adler, dedicated historians of Fort Snelling's Upper Post during WWI and WWII, delve into the haunting 1940 murder of 14-year-old Mary Jane Massey. They discuss the chilling details of her disappearance and the challenges law enforcement faced in the investigation. The duo also examines the fort's rich historical significance and preservation efforts while reflecting on the tragic impact of Mary Jane's unsolved murder on her family and community. Their insight provides a sobering look at both history and crime.

Coffee John Fitchette, a notorious con man and bully, settled in Minneapolis where he started Coffee John's Oyster Grotto. He became friends with Mayor Doc Ames, using his connection to become a police captain while continuing his violent ways. Explore his scandalous life and legend in this true crime history podcast.