
Bad Rap: The Case Against Diddy
For decades, Sean "Diddy" Combs was among the most influential entertainers and entrepreneurs in hip-hop. But Diddy’s star began to implode when a video came out showing the music mogul assaulting his then-girlfriend. There had long been whispers about Diddy's aggression. But critics say his influence and relevance kept the rumors quiet. Until now. A raft of new lawsuits detail shocking allegations of sexual abuse and manipulation orchestrated in so-called "freak offs" -- sex parties Diddy allegedly ordered, videotaped and controlled. Diddy now faces federal charges that include sex trafficking. He has denied all wrongdoing and said all encounters were consensual. A new podcast from 20/20 and ABC Audio traces how whispers of abuse came to light and led to Diddy’s downfall. ABC News legal contributor Brian Buckmire takes listeners inside the rise and fall of Diddy, the allegations and his defense with twice-weekly real-time updates during the trial.
Latest episodes

Jul 8, 2025 • 46min
The Trial: After the Verdict
Last week, the jury in USA v. Sean Combs returned a split verdict. Reactions have been split, too. Lots of people have weighed in -- from Sean Combs’ family to other celebrities, to you: our listeners. As we wrap up trial coverage, ABC News Legal Contributor Brian Buckmire sits down with ABC’s Tonya Simpson to dissect the verdict and process what it might mean for Diddy’s legacy. Also, Brian answers your post-verdict questions. We’ll be back in your feed for Diddy’s sentencing.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Jul 3, 2025 • 15min
The Trial: Split Verdict
The trial verdict for Sean Combs reveals a split outcome that sparks discussion about jury dynamics and the implications of such decisions. Legal insights shed light on what to expect during the upcoming sentencing phase. The conversation delves into how various factors will influence the judge's ruling, including past accusations and public perception. It raises intriguing questions about the fairness of considering previous allegations despite acquittal. Engaging commentary invites listeners to ponder the complexities surrounding high-profile legal cases.

Jul 1, 2025 • 21min
The Trial: Verdict Watch
As the jury begins deliberations, tensions rise over concerns regarding a juror's ability to follow instructions. Legal expert Brian Buckmire delves into the complexities of hung juries and what jurors are allowed to disclose post-trial. The discussion also covers potential sentencing for Sean Combs if convicted and the implications of juror conduct on fairness. Throughout, listeners gain insights into the legal strategies at play and the potential consequences of a mistrial in this high-stakes case.

Jun 27, 2025 • 28min
Burden of Proof: The Defense’s Closing Argument
Bernardo Villalona, an ABC News legal contributor, offers a sharp legal perspective on Sean Combs' trial. He analyzes how the defense reframed the allegations as a narrative about consensual relationships, transforming Combs' predicament into a 'modern love story.' Villalona discusses the role of celebrity status in jury dynamics and the effects of theatricality in courtroom presentations. The closing arguments blend humor with serious allegations, captivating juror engagement while heightening the emotional stakes ahead of the jury's deliberation.

Jun 27, 2025 • 31min
The Trial: The Prosecution’s Closing Argument
Bernarda Villalona, a seasoned defense attorney and former prosecutor, and Shauna Lloyd, managing partner at the Cochran Firm, delve into the intricate closing arguments from the trial against Sean Combs. They dissect the prosecution's attempt to present a compelling case of racketeering and sex trafficking. The conversation highlights strategic legal tactics, the complexities of consent in court, and the looming tension as the jury prepares for deliberation. Their insights reflect on the paramount stakes surrounding high-profile legal battles.

Jun 24, 2025 • 23min
The Trial: Zero Witnesses for the Defense
The podcast dives into the intricate details surrounding Sean Combs' trial, spotlighting both prosecution evidence and defense tactics. It tackles the complex challenges of protecting anonymous witnesses, balancing confidentiality with the need for judicial transparency. The discussion also highlights the ethical responsibilities of media in covering witness anonymity. Additionally, it uncovers the credibility struggles faced by potential witnesses in high-stakes trials, providing a thought-provoking look into the legal system.

Jun 20, 2025 • 33min
The Trial: Who’s the Leak?
Criminal defense attorney Donna Rotunno, known for her work with Harvey Weinstein, joins the discussion on the intense trial involving Sean Combs. They delve into the judge's concerns over leaks and juror misconduct. Donna shares insights on defense strategies amid video evidence and the complexities of consent testimonies. They explore the credibility of alleged victims and the strategic dynamics of cross-examination in sexual assault cases, highlighting how juror demographics can sway perceptions and outcomes in high-profile trials.

Jun 17, 2025 • 25min
The Trial: New Week, New Juror
The trial of Sean Combs gets tense with a juror's dismissal, raising questions about representation and impartiality. As the prosecution edges toward a close, intriguing details about drug evidence and witness testimonies unfold. Explore the complexities of RICO cases, including how defendant numbers impact trial duration. Meanwhile, Kanye West stirs attention with a bold courthouse appearance in support of Combs. It’s a wild mix of legal drama and celebrity antics that keeps listeners on the edge of their seats!

Jun 13, 2025 • 21min
The Trial: “You went to another man's freak-off?”
ABC's chief investigative correspondent, Aaron Katersky, delves into the gripping courtroom drama surrounding Diddy. He discusses a pivotal week of testimony from 'Jane,' who candidly shared her feelings about past relationships and notorious 'hotel nights.' Tensions rise as the defense challenges her credibility regarding interactions with another rapper during a Las Vegas trip. Listeners gain insight into the legal strategies involved in a high-profile trial, especially relating to coercion and the complexities of racketeering charges.

Jun 10, 2025 • 22min
The Trial: “I’m not a sex robot”
Powerful testimonies take center stage, with Jane revealing her haunting experiences that resonate with Cassie's allegations. The jury hears Diddy's voice in compelling audio evidence, creating an intense courtroom atmosphere. The complexities of emotional manipulation emerge, showcasing Jane's struggle between dependence and standing up for herself. Contextual insights into jury nullification and mistrials unpack the high stakes for Diddy, while expert Brian Buckmire answers burning questions about legal proceedings. Intrigue builds as the trial unfolds.