Michael Mackelvie Podcast

Zak Keefer, a sports reporter and author known for his insights on NFL quarterback development, explores the pitfalls young quarterbacks face in the league. He discusses how organizational structures often hinder success, using examples like Andrew Luck and Anthony Richardson. Keefer emphasizes the critical role of coaching fit and scheme, arguing that mismatches can lead to failure. Insights from Bruce Arians and Kevin O'Connell reveal that nurturing through failures is key. This rich conversation sheds light on talent, environment, and the complexities of quarterback development.

In a deep dive with Kevin Cole, a former Senior Data Scientist at Pro Football Focus and analytics guru behind 'Unexpected Points,' they explore the complexities of quarterback performance. Kevin unpacks situational success and the impact of environment on QBs, using Brock Purdy as a case study. He discusses adjusted QB efficiency rankings and when quarterbacks become overrated. They also address historical shifts in expectations and the strategic value of drafting QBs, shedding light on how context shapes evaluation.

Sam Bruchhaus, a senior data scientist at Sumer Sports, dives into the fascinating world of risk in football. He discusses why risk is inherent in play-calling decisions and explores the overlooked effectiveness of play action. The conversation recaps the thrilling 49ers vs. Seahawks game while unpacking quarterback performance metrics. Bruchhaus highlights trends, such as the caution some coaches take that can hinder game strategy, and analyzes players like Daniel Jones and Caleb Williams. This insightful discussion shines a light on the complexities of football analytics.

Kirk Herbstreit, a prominent college football analyst for ESPN's College GameDay, shares insights from his remarkable journey and the shifting landscape of college football. He candidly reveals his challenging childhood and the path that led him to broadcasting. Kirk addresses his fears about the future of college football amidst changing governance and the impact of NIL deals. He also discusses the importance of local game-day traditions, the evolution of quarterback roles, and what’s next for star recruit Arch Manning.