Casefile True Crime

In this insightful discussion, Faye Leveson shares her heart-wrenching journey as the mother of Matthew Leveson, who went missing in 2007. She opens up about family life, detailing Matthew's vibrant childhood and the supportive moment when he came out to his parents. Faye recounts the unsettling events leading to his disappearance, including troubling signs in Matthew's relationship with Michael Atkins. Their family's relentless search for answers reveals the painful hurdles they encountered along the way.

Get ready for some exciting news! The host shares plans for a big 10th anniversary celebration in 2026, filled with new episodes and unreleased premium content. Previously Spotify-exclusive shows will soon reach all platforms. Fans can look forward to multi-part episodes based on listener requests starting in early March. Plus, the dedicated team will keep working tirelessly during the off-season to ensure top-notch quality. Don't forget to follow along on social media for updates and a personal glimpse into the host's life!

The tragic story of Tyler Clementi unfolds as his experiences at Rutgers University reveal the dangers of cyberbullying. From the invasive actions of his roommate Dharun to the poignant consequences of digital humiliation, the narrative highlights the severe impact on LGBTQ+ individuals. The aftermath ignites national conversations about privacy rights, bullying, and the need for advocacy. Tyler's legacy sparks significant policy changes and raises awareness, prompting a vital dialogue about empathy and compassion in our digital age.

A suburban tragedy unfolds as a young girl, Cinnamon, confesses to shooting her stepmother, Linda. The case spirals with shocking family dynamics and allegations of abuse. Initially presumed clear-cut, deeper investigations reveal a web of deceit involving Cinnamon's father, David. His attempts to implicate others and a murder-for-hire plot complicate the narrative. As secrets unravel, the true horrors of manipulation and violence come to light, forever altering the lives involved.

The disturbing case of Malka Leifer unveils a shocking narrative of betrayal within the Adas Israel community. Former students reveal how they trusted a seemingly warm teacher, only to suffer unimaginable abuse. As revelations unfold, we discover the lengthy fight for justice, including her escape to Israel and the sisters' relentless advocacy. Legal battles culminate in a trial that exposes the school’s failures and the cultural barriers to accountability. The impact on survivors resonates powerfully, highlighting their continued fight and the importance of community awareness.

In a gripping tale, the mysterious disappearance of a Cessna during a flight sparks an extensive search effort. A puzzling phone call from a friend hints at a deeper story, leading investigators to question the pilot's claims. Eyewitness accounts and sonar discoveries reveal haunting evidence of a tragic water landing. As authorities piece together the truth, they uncover a web of deceit, with the pilot eventually resurfacing under an alias years later. The case leaves lingering doubts about guilt, intent, and the fine line between accident and foul play.

In a chilling tale, a scrapyard owner named Bruce Miller is murdered, initially appearing to be a robbery gone wrong. After months of dead ends, a former detective's suicide reveals a briefcase containing shocking secrets. A love triangle unfolds as Jerry Cassaday's obsession with Bruce's partner, Cherie, leads to a deadly confrontation. Written confessions and digital evidence unravel a web of deceit and manipulation, causing a dramatic twist in Cherie's trial for murder. The story delves into obsession, betrayal, and the quest for justice.

In 2010, a disturbing figure known as Girl Meat Hunter emerged on a fetish website, openly expressing fantasies of abduction and cannibalism. As online chats escalated with a mentor, plans turned from fantasy to sinister reality. The story delves into a chilling blueprint for kidnapping, unexpected betrayals, and the twists of law enforcement discovery. It raises chilling questions about the line between fantasy and intent, leading to a life sentence and subsequent legal battles over free speech and thought policing.

The brutal murder of respected dermatologist Dr. David Birkett raises questions about motive and identity in this chilling case. Neighbors discover his lifeless body, resulting in a meticulous investigation that reveals a taunting letter and a complex web of evidence. Fingerprints lead to the eventual arrest of Reginald Wilson, culminating in a dramatic trial. The aftermath sees the family's ongoing struggles with the emotional fallout and legal battles post-conviction, shedding light on the lasting effects of violent crime.

A small town in New South Wales becomes the backdrop for a harrowing tale of manipulation and violence involving Roseanne Catt. Allegations reveal a woman who allegedly assaulted her husband through increasingly shocking means. Yet, as the investigation unfolds, troubling evidence arises that questions her conviction. The podcast explores her tumultuous journey from a wrongful imprisonment to a fight for justice. It highlights systemic failures within the legal process while Roseanne reflects on her resilience and pursuit of healing.