Casefile True Crime

Case 357: Wayne & Sharmon Stock

4 snips
Nov 14, 2026
A beloved Nebraska couple is murdered in their farmhouse, launching an investigation marked by family suspicion, a mysterious tan sedan, and a coerced confession. As the case spirals through false leads and wrongful arrests, a gold ring points to the real killers. The fallout exposes planted evidence, a crime lab scandal, and devastating failures of justice.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Investigators Forced The Evidence To Fit

  • The case against Matt and Nick lacked corroboration: the shotgun did not match, DNA excluded them, alibis contradicted the theory, and Matt’s confession contained major errors.
  • Investigators nevertheless pursued a tiny blood trace in Will Sampson’s car until it appeared to validate their preferred narrative.
ANECDOTE

A Stolen Ring Exposed The Real Killers

  • A gold ring found at the farmhouse led investigators through a bankrupt jewelry company’s records to Wisconsin teenager Corey Zastrow.
  • The ring had been stolen from Ryan’s truck during a multistate crime spree, and DNA identified Gregory Fester and Jessica Reed.
ANECDOTE

Jessica Reed Refused To Frame Innocent Men

  • Wisconsin investigators uncovered that Fester and Reed were the only perpetrators, while Nebraska officers pressured them to name Matt, Nick, Will, or Tom.
  • Reed repeatedly corrected the false theory and revealed that two shotguns had been used, a detail never made public.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app