Wisdom of Crowds

Shadi Hamid, a foreign-policy analyst and author, discusses his new book advocating for a morally guided American power. He argues that despite flaws, American democracy is superior to that of global rivals like Russia and China. Matt Duss, former advisor to Bernie Sanders, offers a critical viewpoint, questioning which version of America might wield power and discussing the moral authority of U.S. foreign policy. The two explore themes of hypocrisy, accountability, and how the U.S. can improve its international stance while balancing domestic needs.

Jamie Kirchick, a writer and commentator known for his insights on conservatism and LGBTQ issues, dissects the impact of media figures like Tucker Carlson and Nick Fuentes. He argues that Fuentes has gained notoriety due to Carlson's platforming, revealing a deep rot in conservative institutions. The discussion touches on rising anti-Semitism among youth, generational shifts in pro-Israel sentiment, and the moral failings pervading modern conservatism. Kirchick warns that these trends showcase a troubling future for the Republican Party and American politics.

Tamar Gendler, a Yale philosopher specializing in philosophical psychology, delves into the nature of trust and its political implications. She debates whether humans are naturally suspicious or inherently social beings. Gendler discusses the importance of context in trust, contrasting Hobbes' individualism with Aristotle's view of humans as community-oriented. The conversation also explores how institutions can restore trust and prevent betrayal, highlighting the delicate balance between communal harmony and the need for security.

Leah Libresco Sargeant, an author and policy advocate, discusses her book, The Dignity of Dependence. She emphasizes that women's equality should not rely on interchangeability with men. The conversation explores reframing dependence as a normal part of life and proposes policies like caregiver credits. Leah critiques rigid workplace norms that disadvantage pregnant workers and argues for designing jobs for human bodies. The hosts debate the balance between natural differences and societal changes, ultimately advocating for mutual care in communities.

Tyler Cowen, an economics professor at George Mason University and acclaimed author, dives into the complexities of contemporary America. He discusses the essence of Trumpism and its historical roots, highlighting America's unique liberal values and the tensions surrounding the American Dream. Cowen explores the impact of technology and AI on political community, arguing it may centralize power while also raising questions of national sovereignty. He emphasizes that despite challenges, the U.S. maintains an unusual level of unity amidst populist trends.

In this engaging discussion, Harvard philosopher Michael J. Sandel shares insights on community, democracy, and why public moral discourse matters. His son, Adam Sandel, adds depth by discussing the fragility of institutions and how modern pressures lead to isolation. Music director Teddy Abrams illustrates how arts can mend civic divides, showcasing the Louisville Orchestra's innovative residency programs. Together, they explore rebuilding community ties and engaging in meaningful deliberation, emphasizing the importance of shared experiences for a healthier democracy.

Robert Malley, a veteran American diplomat and Middle East expert, discusses his new book, focusing on the deep historical and emotional roots of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He argues that past traumas shape today's responses and critiques the limitations of liberal peacemaking. Malley emphasizes that any solution must acknowledge both sides' core yearnings. The conversation also explores the potential for generational shifts in U.S. policy to foster peace, while suggesting alternative frameworks to the traditional two-state solution.

In this engaging discussion, Samuel Kimbriel, a philosopher-in-residence, and Shadi Hamid, a political analyst, delve into the complex interplay between Christianity and politics. Kimbriel explores the tensions of aligning faith with political success, while Hamid critiques the use of religion in American political narratives. They examine the implications of forgiveness in politics, question the existence of a 'true' Christianity, and reflect on how faith shapes public life. Together, they challenge conventional views, making for a thought-provoking dialogue.

In this conversation, Jordan Castro, a writer and deputy director of the Cluny Project, discusses his new novel, Muscle Man. He explores themes of masculinity, loneliness, and the mind-body connection. Castro delves into the protagonist's self-loathing and how weightlifting serves as a coping mechanism. The chat also highlights the novel's anti-campus elements, the role of humor, and the impact of modern alienation. Castro emphasizes the need for empathy in understanding flawed characters amidst today's societal pressures.

Geoff Shullenberger, managing editor of Compact and a political culture writer, dives into the disturbing rise of targeted political assassinations, spurred by recent events like the assassination of Charlie Kirk. He examines how the landscape of political violence has transformed, moving from mass shootings to precise hits. Historical comparisons to 1960s radicals provide context, while discussions around left- versus right-wing violence blur traditional labels. Ultimately, Geoff suggests much of this violence might be senseless, challenging our need for meaning.