Wisdom of Crowds Will the Right Sideline Nick Fuentes? Can it?
Nov 8, 2025
Jamie Kirchick, a writer and commentator known for his insights on conservatism and LGBTQ issues, dissects the impact of media figures like Tucker Carlson and Nick Fuentes. He argues that Fuentes has gained notoriety due to Carlson's platforming, revealing a deep rot in conservative institutions. The discussion touches on rising anti-Semitism among youth, generational shifts in pro-Israel sentiment, and the moral failings pervading modern conservatism. Kirchick warns that these trends showcase a troubling future for the Republican Party and American politics.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Tucker, Not Fuentes, Drives The Moment
- Tucker Carlson, not Nick Fuentes, is the main problem because he gives Fuentes mainstream reach and legitimacy.
- Carlson is pushing an isolationist, anti‑Israel line that reshapes Republican discourse and draws young followers.
Heritage's Reaction Exposed Institutional Rot
- Kevin Roberts's defense of Tucker revealed deep problems in conservative institutions and their tolerance for extremist views.
- Roberts framed engagement with young Fuentes followers as outreach, normalizing platforming rather than ostracism.
Deny Platforms, Not Rights
- Ostracize, don't criminalize: refuse to platform extremist figures rather than arguing about legal rights.
- Institutions should avoid giving stages to people whose presence would taint them.
