

Shameless Popery
Catholic Answers
Shameless Popery is a witty, entertaining podcast that informs you about your Catholic faith and equips you to better explain Catholicism especially to Protestant or atheist friends.
Episodes
Mentioned books

9 snips
Jun 17, 2025 • 0sec
#182 You’re misunderstanding “Love” and “Hate” in Romans 9 - Joe Heschmeyer
Delve into the nuanced meanings of 'love' and 'hate' in biblical texts, particularly in the stories of Jacob and Esau. Discover how common translations can mislead readers and overlook profound historical understandings. Learn about the Hebrew words 'aheb' and 'sanah,' and their implications on divine relationships and covenants. This exciting discussion challenges traditional interpretations by emphasizing the importance of context in grasping God’s choices and the dynamics of biblical love.

Jun 12, 2025 • 0sec
#181 Did Redeemed Zoomer Strawman My Argument Against Calvinism? - Joe Heschmeyer
Dive into the heated world of theological debate as Joe Heschmeyer takes on a Calvinist critique and challenges the notion of strawmanning. He highlights the importance of accurately representing opposing views, while tackling common misconceptions around Calvinism and predestination. The discussion emphasizes intellectual charity and the necessity for informed dialogue. Drawing attention to key figures in Calvinism, Joe calls for clarity in doctrinal interpretation, all while critiquing superficial arguments in contemporary religious discussions.

Jun 10, 2025 • 0sec
#180 “God Probably Hates You…” | How Calvinism Breaks Logic - Joe Heschmeyer
Dive into the intriguing contradictions of Calvinism, where logic seems to break down under scrutiny. Explore how the doctrine of limited atonement raises questions about salvation and personal faith. The discussion challenges the nature of God's love for humanity, contrasting Calvinist views with traditional beliefs. It delves into the complex relationship between divine love, justice, and glory, revealing potential inconsistencies in how love is defined within Calvinist thought. Prepare for a fascinating theological debate!

31 snips
Jun 5, 2025 • 0sec
#179 Throwing Out Scripture to Save Sola Scriptura - Joe Heschmeyer
Dive into the fascinating debate over the ending of the Gospel of Mark, with three theories presented on its mysterious conclusion. Explore the challenges of authorship and divine inspiration as the complexities of biblical canon take center stage. Delve into interpretations of key figures like Mary Magdalene and the stylistic distinctions in the Gospels. Joe also tackles the contentious issues surrounding Mark 16 and its theological implications, questioning the foundation of scriptural authority in relation to Sola Scriptura.

25 snips
Jun 3, 2025 • 0sec
#178 The Christian Way to Respond to Pride Month… - Joe Heschmeyer
The discussion highlights the connection between Pride Month and the Sacred Heart of Jesus. Joe emphasizes responding to contemporary challenges with love and hope, drawing on the rainbow as a symbol of divine affection. He addresses the struggle to uphold Christian values amid societal pressures and calls for deeper relationships with Jesus. The podcast advocates for compassion and understanding in how Christians engage with sin, urging transformative love and genuine devotion to guide interactions and foster spiritual growth.

26 snips
May 29, 2025 • 0sec
#177 Why “Faith Alone” Is No Answer to “Baptism Saves You” - Joe Heschmeyer
Dive into a compelling discussion on the link between baptism and salvation, challenging the idea that faith alone suffices. Explore early Christian views that highlight baptism as essential for salvation. The conversation also tackles personal biases in debates, revealing how they impact reasoning, especially on religious topics. Additionally, learn about the complexities of church teachings and the surprising practices surrounding baptism fees today, connecting historical beliefs to modern-day interpretations.

9 snips
May 27, 2025 • 0sec
#176 6 Bible Verses PROVING Water Baptism Saves (REBUTTAL to @NeedGodnet) - Joe Heschmeyer
Joe dives into a heated debate over the role of water baptism in salvation. He presents six pivotal Bible verses that argue baptism is not just symbolic but essential. The discussion includes the authenticity of the closing verses in Mark and the interpretation of 'born of water and the Spirit' from John. Additionally, he highlights Peter's message in Acts 2:38 and challenges views that dismiss baptism's significance in faith. Reflexively, he critiques the idea that belief alone is sufficient for salvation, reinforcing the integral relationship between belief and baptism.

20 snips
May 22, 2025 • 0sec
#175 5 Bad Catholic Arguments We NEED TO STOP Using… - Joe Heschmeyer
Explore five ineffective arguments often used in Catholic-Protestant dialogues that need to go. Discover how seeking common ground can transform conversations about contentious issues like abortion. Learn to employ effective persuasion techniques, including the Socratic method, to enhance understanding. Delve into the complexities of denominational diversity and why it's crucial to avoid generalizations. Hear tips for crafting clear and compelling arguments that respect opposing viewpoints.

7 snips
May 20, 2025 • 0sec
#174 Martin Luther’s Narcissistic War on Philosophy… - Joe Heschmeyer
Explore Martin Luther's shocking rejection of Aristotle and how it shaped the clash between faith and reason. The discussion dives into Luther's controversial self-perception, portraying himself as a modern-day Noah. Delve into the implications of his criticisms on philosophy and the legacy of his radical theology. The examination raises fascinating questions about motivations behind his break from tradition and the impact it had on Christianity in the 16th century.

59 snips
May 15, 2025 • 0sec
#172 Ranking the BEST (and worst) Arguments AGAINST Catholicism (tier list) - Joe Heschmeyer
Joe dives into a tier list ranking Protestant arguments against Catholicism, evaluating their effectiveness. He critiques Sola Scriptura and examines the development of doctrine. Common misconceptions about cultural celebrations and the Pope are debunked. The significance of living a saintly life as a means of evangelization shines through, alongside a discussion on the role of dogma in understanding salvation. The podcast champions respectful dialogue and clarifies Catholic identity against historical myths.