Writer and broadcaster Helen Lewis discusses the history of anti-suffragettes, exploring why women were against female enfranchisement, the failings of men, and where these arguments can still be heard today. The podcast delves into the fear and suspicion surrounding women's suffrage, the radical actions of suffragettes, the influence of anti-suffrage movements on modern American politics, and the resurfacing of past arguments in contemporary gender debates.
Opposition to suffrage focused on preserving traditional female power in the home, fearing women's entry into male-dominated politics.
Biological differences were used to argue women's unsuitability for politics, reinforcing deep-seated biases against women.
Despite historical resistance, the suffragette movement challenged stereotypes and paved the way for women's political engagement.
Deep dives
Arguments Against Female Suffrage in the Early 20th Century
In the early 20th century, a movement called the Women's Anti-Suffrage League emerged, opposing women's right to vote. The argument presented was that women already held power in specific spheres like the home and giving them the vote would dilute this power. The idea was that women entering the political realm dominated by men would diminish their influence. Despite articulate views against enfranchisement, concerns about losing traditional female power persisted.
Challenges and Perceptions of Women in Politics
Beyond the suffrage debate, the idea that women were not suited for politics based on biological differences was prevalent. Men in power were not subjected to the same scrutiny. The notion that female politicians would be erratic or unhappy due to their gender was raised. Concerns about decision-making in war by women, contrasting with male-dominated military environments, highlighted deep-rooted biases against women in political and public life.
Evolution of Female Political Participation
Historically, women's political participation faced opposition with arguments like women not desiring the vote or not being driven for success like men. The suffragette movement challenged stereotypes of female capabilities, even resorting to violent protests. Despite initial hesitations, the rise of female politicians and shifts in public attitudes have demonstrated women's competence and commitment to political engagement over time.
Historical Context of Women's Enfranchisement in the United States
The discussion delves into the historical context of women's suffrage in the United States, highlighting the enduring arguments for and against enfranchisement since the 19th century. It mentions how anti-suffrage sentiments persist to this day, manifesting in potential voter suppression tactics that may extend beyond racial discrimination. The conversation reflects on the societal repercussions of social revolutions in the 60s, 70s, and 80s that sparked a contentious reaction in America, echoing past arguments in modern contexts.
Challenges in Contemporary Feminist Discourse and Political Landscapes
The episode navigates through the complexities of contemporary feminist discourse, particularly in political spheres, examining the need for nuanced arguments beyond traditional rights-based feminism. It sheds light on the evolving nature of feminism, where demands for special treatments based on gender differences challenge conventional notions of equality. Additionally, it critiques the impact of gender politics in political leadership scenarios, including the intersecting influences of historical gender perceptions and modern political landscapes.
In this episode of our series on the lingering hold of bad ideas David talks to the writer and broadcaster Helen Lewis about the arguments made at the turn of the last century against giving the vote to women. Why were so many women against female enfranchisement? What did attitudes to women in politics reveal about the failings of men? And where can the echoes of these arguments still be heard today?
Helen Lewis’s Difficult Women: A History of Feminism in 11 Fights is available wherever you get your books https://bit.ly/3wp8DNX
Sign up now to PPF+ to get ad-free listening and bonus episodes to accompany every series. Coming soon: two bonus bad ideas just for PPF+ subscribers www.ppfideas.com
Next time on The History of Bad Ideas: Kathleen Stock discusses The Death of the Author.
