In this engaging discussion, Robert Shrimsley, an insightful commentator on British and international politics, and Gideon Rachman, the FT's Chief Foreign Affairs Commentator, dive into the shifting dynamics between Europe and the US. They grapple with the potential rearmament across Europe amid rising threats and analyze America's reliability as an ally. The episode also features a look at the emerging right-wing movement, blending politics with faith and reshaping cultural narratives, all while assessing the implications for identity and defense in a changing world.
Keir Starmer's visit to the White House symbolizes a critical effort to redefine UK diplomatic relations in a changing US-European dynamic.
The rise of right-wing ideologies at events like the ARC conference indicates a significant cultural shift impacting Western political discourse and unity.
Deep dives
Keir Starmer's Diplomacy Challenge
Keir Starmer's upcoming visit to the White House represents a significant moment for British diplomacy as he aims to establish himself as a bridge between the US and Europe. There are expectations that his leadership could fill a perceived vacuum in European politics, especially with leaders like Schultz and Macron potentially stepping back. However, skepticism exists regarding whether the US is truly looking for such an intermediary role, as historically it has preferred to communicate directly. This context raises questions about the feasibility of Starmer's ambitions amidst the shifting dynamics of US-European relations, particularly in light of Donald Trump's recent foreign policy actions.
Trump's Shifting Allegiances
Donald Trump's recent statements and actions have raised concerns about his administration's alignment with Russia, creating unease among European allies. His characterization of Ukraine's leadership and his suggestions that the US may act independently in negotiations have led some to perceive the US as not only unreliable but adversarial. This change in tone has provoked varying reactions in Europe, where discussions are underway to strategize independently of US influence. European nations are beginning to prepare for a future where reliance on American support may be diminished, underscoring the shifting balance of power.
The Rise of Right-Wing Ideologies
The ARC conference in London highlighted the increasing acceptance and visibility of right-wing ideologies within Western political discourse, particularly those rooted in Judeo-Christian values. Key figures from various sectors gathered to discuss themes such as family structure, mass immigration, and opposition to net-zero policies, framing them as existential crises facing Western civilization. This gathering demonstrated a widening ideological divide and the potential for mobilizing a significant political movement in response to perceived threats to traditional values. The emergence of these coalitions suggests that the cultural and political landscape is shifting towards a more consolidated right-wing narrative.
The Fragility of European Security
European leaders are increasingly voicing concerns over the durability of US security guarantees amidst the Trump administration's unpredictable foreign policy. As the possibility of US disengagement looms, European capitals are considering their own defense strategies and preparing for potential military realignments without American support. This uncertainty has prompted some nations, like Denmark, to bolster their defense spending significantly. However, challenges remain, as Europe grapples with the logistical and strategic complexities of filling any potential void left by the US, reflecting a critical moment in transatlantic relations.
The future of Ukraine and the defence of Europe will dominate when Keir Starmer jets out to the White House for talks with Donald Trump next week. Can the UK prime minister help save 80 years of Pax Americana? Or is the US on the verge of becoming an ‘adversary’ to Europe? Host Lucy Fisher is joined by FT colleagues Robert Shrimsley, Gideon Rachman and John Paul Rathbone to discuss the military implications for Britain and Europe, as calls grow for rapid rearmament across the continent.
Plus, the FT’s media editor Dan Thomas joins the panel to lift the lid on the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship (Arc) conference this week, at which Nigel Farage, Jordan Peterson and Kemi Badenoch spoke. Part ‘megachurch’, part political rally, Lucy, Dan and Robert unravel what the movement is.
Sign up here for 30 free days of Stephen Bush's Inside Politics newsletter, winner of the World Association of News Publishers 2023 ‘Best Newsletter’ award.
Presented by Lucy Fisher. Produced by Lulu Smyth. The executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Original music and mixed by Breen Turner. The FT’s head of audio is Cheryl Brumley.