Shameless Popery #159 Gay Atheist vs. Catholic Sexual Morality DEBATE review - Joe Heschmeyer
55 snips
Apr 3, 2025 A thought-provoking debate unfolds between a former Catholic turned atheist and a defender of Catholic sexual ethics. They tackle contentious topics like gay marriage and the misconceptions surrounding morality. The conversation dives into natural law, exploring its impact on human flourishing and child outcomes in same-sex households. They analyze studies on family structures, critique empirical evidence, and discuss moral absolutes within Catholic doctrine. Ultimately, the dialogue blends reason and faith in understanding complex moral issues.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Cade's Background
- Joe Heschmeyer's guest, Cade, once a traditional Catholic, now identifies as an atheist.
- Cade's journey included a period of discerning Carmelite monkhood and studying philosophy near Catholic Answers.
Misunderstanding Morality
- Many misunderstand moral law as arbitrary, externally imposed, and limiting.
- True morality is rooted in human nature, internally felt, and essential for flourishing.
Natural Law's Scope
- Natural law, knowable through reason, is often mistaken as solely Catholic.
- It's written on human hearts, evidenced by universal moral intuitions like opposing theft.
