
EconTalk Shampoo, Property Rights, and Civilization (with Anthony Gill)
Nov 10, 2025
In this engaging discussion, political scientist Anthony Gill, a professor at the University of Washington, dives into why we feel entitled to take little shampoo bottles from hotels but not towels. He explores the role of social norms in enforcing property rights, backed by famous economists like Adam Smith and Friedrich Hayek. Gill delves into how flexible, unwritten rules can often be more effective than rigid laws, and warns against the erosion of trust and norms in society. His insights highlight the fascinating interplay between moral sentiments and everyday behavior.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Government Is Not The Everyday Enforcer
- People default to saying the government enforces property rights, but most individuals never read the laws that supposedly define them.
- Social norms, not formal codes, govern everyday property claims in many situations.
Shampoo Bottles Sparked A Puzzle
- Anthony Gill collects hotel mini-shampoo bottles and noticed hotels switching to wall dispensers.
- That shift sparked his puzzle about why small bottles are allowed to be taken but dispensers are not.
Implicit Entitlements Versus Social Lines
- People treat small hotel amenities as implicitly included in the room price while rejecting taking larger items.
- The line between acceptable and unacceptable taking is socially constructed, not strictly legal.







