Colorblindness is about acknowledging race and then treating people without regard to it, not denying racism.
Acknowledging racial inequality is necessary to effectively address it and combat racism.
Understanding the context and nuances of historical language is important when discussing the principles of colorblindness.
Focusing on class-based policies while treating everyone equally can address racial disparities and benefit marginalized racial groups.
Deep dives
Colorblindness as the antidote to racism
Coleman Hughes argues that colorblindness is the antidote to racism. He believes that once race is acknowledged, the commitment to treating people without regard to it can begin. He points to historical examples of civil rights leaders, such as Wendell Phillips, who advocated for a colorblind government. Hughes emphasizes that colorblindness is not about pretending race doesn't exist, but rather about treating people equally despite their race. He argues that race-conscious policies, such as affirmative action, are actually detrimental and perpetuate racism.
The importance of acknowledging inequality
Jamel Bowie argues that colorblindness turns a blind eye to inequality and perpetuates racism. He asserts that acknowledging racial inequality is necessary to address it effectively. Bowie cites examples of racial disparities and argues that pretending these disparities don't exist hinders progress. He highlights the importance of class-based policies to combat inequality, emphasizing that class-based approaches will disproportionately benefit marginalized racial groups.
Historical perspective on colorblindness
Bowie challenges Hughes' historical references, particularly Wendell Phillips, arguing that Phillips used the term 'colorblind' in the context of rejecting race hierarchy, rather than denying the existence of race. He points out that historical figures like Phillips were advocating for government policies that rejected racism and addressed racial subordination. Bowie suggests that understanding the context and nuances of historical language is important when discussing the principles of colorblindness.
The concept of colorblindness evolves over time
Hughes responds to Bowie by reiterating that colorblindness is about acknowledging race and then treating people without regard to it. He argues that colorblindness is not a denial of racism, but the most effective way to fight against it. Hughes references contemporary policies that prioritize race and argues that they perpetuate racism rather than solve the underlying issues. He emphasizes the need to focus on class-based policies while treating everyone equally, which will benefit marginalized racial groups as well.
Colorblindness vs. Reality
The debate centers around the dichotomy between colorblindness and acknowledging the reality of racial inequality. While some argue for colorblindness, others argue that race-conscious policies are necessary to address group inequalities.
Historical Perspectives on Colorblindness
The discussion delves into the views of historical figures like Wendell Phillips, Martin Luther King Jr., and Bayard Rustin. While there are different interpretations of their beliefs, the focus is on whether they supported race-conscious policies or advocated for colorblindness.
Addressing Group Inequalities
The conversation revolves around the question of how to address group inequalities, specifically racial disparities. Some argue that race-conscious policies are needed to tackle race-based inequality, while others propose focusing on class-based approaches to address socioeconomic disparities.
Ben Burgis and Victor Bruzzone continue GTAA's weekly series of Thursday Night Debate Breakdowns by watching a recent debate between podcaster (and former Manhattan Institute fellow) Coleman Hughes and New York Times columnist Jamelle Bouie on the topic "Does Color-Blindness Perpetuate Racism?" (Bouie says yes, Hughes says no.) They both say partially true things, but this voice could use several hundred times more Adolph Reed.
Follow Victor on Twitter: @victorbruzzone
Follow Ben on Twitter: @BenBurgis
Follow GTAA on Twitter: @Gtaa_Show
Become a GTAA Patron and receive numerous benefits ranging from patron-exclusive postgames every Monday and Thursday night to the Discord server to occasional advance and exclusive content to our undying love and gratitude for helping us keep this thing going:
patreon.com/benburgis
Read the weekly philosophy Substack:
benburgis.substack.com
Visit benburgis.com
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
