Taiwan's military faces readiness challenges and lacks effective defense strategy against a potential PLA invasion.
US military intervention uncertainty increases as public confidence in support for Taiwan declines, influenced by PLA's advancing capabilities.
Deep dives
Taiwan's Military Readiness
Taiwan's military readiness is questioned, highlighting significant gaps and deficiencies in its current defense strategy. The discussion focuses on the lack of preparedness for a potential invasion by the PLA, emphasizing critical errors in the US Department of Defense report regarding Taiwan's military capabilities. The inadequacy of Taiwan's reserve force to mobilize effectively in modern warfare scenarios is highlighted, raising concerns about its ability to withstand an invasion.
US Response and PLA Capabilities
Discussions delve into the likelihood of US military intervention in the event of a PLA invasion of Taiwan, highlighting a decline in public confidence in such support. The PLA's increasing capabilities, including its satellite fleet expansion and strategic advancements, are emphasized, influencing potential US decision-making on intervention based on the perceived risks and implications.
Political Interference and Military Decision-Making
Critiques are directed towards Taiwan's political leadership for interfering in military appointments and decisions, compromising the effectiveness of the military for political gains. The questionable allocation of resources, such as the purchase of additional F-16 jets, is highlighted as strategically irrelevant given the expected challenges during an invasion scenario, reflecting an overall lack of coherent defense strategy.
Global Response and Potential Outcomes
The potential global responses to a PLA invasion of Taiwan are discussed, exploring the considerations of international allies and the implications of a large-scale conflict. The psychological and strategic factors influencing international actions in the face of Chinese aggression are debated, questioning the feasibility and consequences of various scenarios, including the role of economic and geopolitical factors in shaping outcomes.
Paul Huang, Taiwan military expert and research fellow at the Taiwan Public Opinion Foundation, returns to ChinaTalk! Today he gives us an update on Taiwan’s military readiness, the PLA’s expansion, and whether Xi Jinping would really send it.
If you missed his episode back in 2020, give it a listen, too. And check out his recent thoughts posted on NBR, as well as his long-form special report, “Threats to Taiwan’s Security from China’s Military Modernization.”
In this episode, we cover:
The status quo of Taiwan’s reservist forces and command-and-control capabilities — and how Western countries perceive that status quo;
How the PLA’s military capabilities stack up against Russia’s performance in the Ukraine war thus far;
What insights we can glean from PLA-facing propaganda;
Why Ukrainian forces have been successful in repelling the Russian military thus far, and why Xi Jinping would loathe a protracted war over Taiwan;
Paul’s take on the PLA’s recent military maneuvers against US and Canadian assets in the Taiwan Strait and South China Sea;
What the Taiwanese populace believes about PLA military action, US military support for Taiwan — and why these trends have changed over time;
China’s robust satellite expansion program, and how it plays a role in its aircraft carrier “kill chain”;
Likely and unlikely PLA invasion scenarios — and the corresponding discussions that would occur in the White House;
What Taiwan military officials — like Admiral Lee Hsi-ming (Ret.) 李喜明 — think about Taiwan’s military readiness for an invasion.