“Therapy Is Preventing Kids From Growing Up.” - Author Abigail Shrier
Apr 5, 2024
auto_awesome
Investigative journalist Abigail Shrier discusses how therapy has stunted a generation, problems with Gentle Parenting, kids in conservative vs liberal households, and the risks and limitations of therapy. The podcast delves into the lack of objective measures in therapy, the consequences of gentle parenting on child development, and the impact of different parenting styles on children. It also touches on media influence on health, school counseling practices, and the importance of exposing children to distress for emotional resilience.
Therapy may have adverse effects and not always lead to improved mental health in children and teenagers.
Authoritative parenting with clear rules fosters happier children, while avoiding boundaries can hinder independence and coping skills.
Kids from liberal households may lack structure, leading to extremist group affiliations, potentially linked to therapy dependency and emotional numbness.
Deep dives
The Effects of Therapy on Children and Teens
Children and teenagers are increasingly being introduced to therapy for various issues, with the idea that therapy can help improve mental health. However, the podcast delves into the potential downsides of this trend. It highlights that despite the increasing availability of therapy, the emotional well-being of kids is not necessarily improving. The discussion raises concerns about overdiagnosis and potential harms of therapy, emphasizing the importance of considering the risks alongside the benefits.
Parenting Styles and Their Impact on Children
The podcast delves into the influence of different parenting styles on child development. It mentions that authoritative parenting, which combines love with clear rules and expectations, tends to nurture the happiest and most well-adjusted children. In contrast, the trend towards avoiding saying 'no' or setting boundaries, seen in some modern parenting approaches, may undermine children's ability to cope with challenges and develop independence.
The Rise of Extremism and Therapy Dependency in Young Adults
The podcast discusses how young adults from liberal families are seen to be more prone to joining politically extreme groups like Antifa or white supremacist movements. It points out that these individuals often come from environments where rules and boundaries were lacking, leading them to seek out more structured settings. Additionally, the conversation raises concerns about how therapy dependency and a lack of resilience in childhood may contribute to emotional numbness and dependency in adulthood, potentially impacting decision-making and societal dynamics.
The Impact of New Parenting Approaches on Children's Behavior
There is a discussion on how parents raising kids who crave structure and discipline are increasingly turning to new parenting approaches, like 'gentle parenting', influenced by therapists and psychologists. These approaches often involve avoiding traditional disciplinary measures and prioritizing emotional understanding over consequences. The podcast explores the potential consequences of such parenting styles, pointing out concerns over emotional dysregulation, chaos in schools, and the rise of mental health interventions.
Critique of Social-Emotional Learning in Schools
The podcast delves into the prevalence of social-emotional learning (SEL) programs in schools, which focus on teaching emotional regulation and coping techniques. However, critics argue that these programs may inadvertently contribute to increased sadness, anxiety, and alienation from parents among children. The discussion highlights concerns about the emphasis on trauma narratives, potential ethical issues related to school counselors' roles, and the need to balance resilience-building experiences with emotional support in children's development.
Did you know that there are negative side effects to therapy? No of course you didn't, because NO ONE talks about it. Investigative journalist and author Abigail Shrier is back to discuss her new book Bad Therapy, which reveals how the overuse of therapy has mentally stunted an entire generation. Alex and Abigail discuss problems with Gentle Parenting and how kids fare in conservative vs liberal households.
.
Get ticket details for Turning Point USA’s Young Women’s Leadership Summit at https://ywls2024.com and use code ALEX for 25% off admission!
Interested in making a tax deductible donation to support The Spillover? ☕️ Visit https://donate.tpusa.com/donate to contribute to guest travel, set needs and more!
.
Elevate your skincare routine with NIMI SKINCARE! Go to https://www.nimiskincare.com/ and use promo code ALEXCLARK to get 10% off your order.
Get 100% Organic tampons & now PADS! Try GARNUU today at https://garnuu.com/ and use code ALEX for 15% off.
Ditch artificial fragrances for your family by switching to ALEAVIA organic prebiotic body wash and use code: ALEX15 for 15% off. https://www.aleavia.com/
.
Looking for like-minded friends? Join the Cuteservative Facebook group: / 1234544066933796
Interested in making a tax deductible donation to support The Spillover? ☕️✨ Visit https://donate.tpusa.com/donate to contribute to guest travel, set needs and more!
Listen at 6 PM PST/ 9 PM EST every Thursday by subscribing to ‘The Spillover’ on Apple Podcasts and Spotify ☕️✨