Explore the extravagant world of VIP nightclubs and the labor conditions for models. Delve into the social dynamics and rationality within exclusive nightclubs and the role of luxury consumption. Examine the complexities of race and advantage in the industry. Uncover the dynamics of high-end hostessing and the transformation of clubs in New York City. Discuss the concept of pleasure and exploitation in exclusive spaces and reflect on the possibilities of creating a more inclusive VIP club.
The VIP club scene perpetuates social hierarchies and rigid structures that benefit the wealthy elite.
Excessive spending in VIP clubs serves as a means for the ultra-rich to showcase their status and wealth while generating moral ambiguity.
Promoters play crucial roles in bringing wealthy clients and beautiful women to VIP clubs, perpetuating discriminatory dynamics and beauty standards.
Luxury consumption and the VIP club scene reflect larger issues of economic inequality, wealth concentration, and moral values of the ruling class.
Deep dives
Overview of the VIP club scene
The podcast episode explores the world of VIP clubs, focusing on the extravagant spending and consumption habits of the ultra-rich. It delves into the garish displays of wealth, such as bottle service and champagne wars, that are carefully choreographed in these exclusive clubs. The podcast highlights the social hierarchies and rigid social structures that undergird the VIP party circuit. It also examines the role of promoters who are responsible for bringing in beautiful women to enhance the experience for the wealthy clients. The episode discusses how these excessive displays of luxury consumption contribute to the perpetuation of economic inequality and the moral economy of the ruling class.
The motivations behind VIP club spending
The podcast episode explores the motivations behind the excessive spending and conspicuous consumption in the VIP club scene. It delves into the desires of the wealthy clients to showcase their status and wealth through lavish displays of waste. The guests interviewed in the episode reveal that while they may engage in such behavior, they also express unease and moral ambiguity about their own spending habits. The episode discusses how the pursuit of status through extravagant consumption plays a role in the social world and moral economy of the elite. It also highlights the economic implications of such spending in maintaining global capitalism.
The role of promoters and girls in the VIP club scene
The episode examines the crucial roles played by promoters and the girls in the functioning of the VIP club scene. Promoters, who are often men from non-privileged backgrounds, are responsible for bringing in wealthy clients and beautiful women to the clubs. They use their relational skills to build friendships and connections with models and other women, offering favors and opportunities in exchange for their presence. The episode also highlights the discriminatory dynamics and expectations surrounding the entrance into VIP clubs, with a focus on the beauty standards imposed on women. Additionally, it discusses the racial dynamics within the VIP club scene, with the episode pointing out the predominance of white attendees and the importance placed on fostering relationships with white individuals for networking purposes.
Implications of the VIP club scene
The podcast episode delves into the wider implications of the VIP club scene. It examines how the global ultra-wealthy engage in excessive consumption and conspicuous displays of wealth as a means of status acquisition. The episode argues that such behavior is enabled by the conditions of 21st-century capitalism, highlighting the critiques and moral unease associated with this form of spending. It also discusses how the VIP club scene reflects larger issues of economic inequality and the impact of wealth concentration on society. The episode offers insights into the social significance of luxury consumption and the moral values of the ruling class.
The Rise of Bottle Service in Nightclubs
One of the main shifts in the nightclub scene discussed in the podcast is the rise of bottle service as a way to cater to the desires of wealthy clients. Bottle service initially started as a convenience to reduce wait times at the bar, but quickly transformed into a status symbol and a means of distinction. The clubs shifted their focus from general admission to catering to wealthy clients who could afford expensive bottles and tables. This transformation coincided with the increase in economic inequality and the concentration of wealth in certain professions. The clubs started operating in areas like the meatpacking district in Manhattan, which experienced gentrification due to the influx of wealthy people. The shift towards catering to elite tastes had a poisoning effect on the ecosystem, as the entire enterprise became oriented around meeting the whims and desires of the ultra-wealthy clients. The promoters aspired to achieve the same level of conspicuous consumption as their wealthy clients, creating a cascade effect in which the entire system revolved around these rich individuals.
The Exploitation and Pleasure in the Nightlife Industry
The podcast delves into the complex dynamics of exploitation and pleasure within the nightlife industry. It explores how girls working in clubs are both exploited and experience pleasure in their participation. The labor of these girls is deliberately defined as leisure and not paid work, adding to the challenge of dismantling the system of exploitation. The promoters play a crucial role in constructing the relationship between the girls and the clients as fun, meaningful, and reciprocal, which contributes to the girls' enjoyment. However, the pleasure they derive from being part of the scene also reinforces gender hierarchies and exclusions. The podcast highlights the difficulty of challenging a system that offers pleasure and perceived inclusion, even when labor exploitation is evident.
Changes in New York Nightlife and the Future
The podcast mentions the changes in New York City nightlife, particularly the meatpacking district, over the past few decades. The area transformed from a desolate place associated with sex work to a playground for the ultra-wealthy. The rise of bottle service and the concentration of clubs in the area contributed to this transformation. However, the podcast also discusses the possibility of more inclusive forms of nightlife arising, such as the resurgence of mass promotions for clubs driven by ticket sales and the emergence of private social clubs. Despite potential changes in the content of consumption, hierarchy and exclusions are likely to persist in the nightlife industry due to economic inequality and wealth concentration. The podcast ultimately raises questions about the future of nightlife and the possibility of creating clubs that are both inclusive and profitable.
Featuring Ashley Mears on her book Very Important People: Status and Beauty in the Global Party Circuit. Mears, a sociologist and former fashion model, explores the super-elite "models and bottles" party scene where beautiful young women and conspicuous consumption heighten the status of rich men.
Support The Dig at Patreon.com/TheDig
Contact Spotify and tell them: stop hiding The Dig! Why is The Dig so hard to find on Spotify? support.spotify.com/contact-spotify-support
Buy Against Erasure: A Photographic Memory of Palestine before the Nakba at haymarketbooks.org/books/2325-against-erasure
Subscribe to a year of Jacobin for only $15. A special offer for Dig listeners! bit.ly/digjacobin
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
