The Commentary Magazine Podcast We're Opening the Mailbag
11 snips
Jul 25, 2025 In a lively discussion, the hosts tackle listener critiques and their own missteps with humor. They explore historical figures like Henry II and the challenges of modern American identity, examining why some progressives struggle to connect with national pride. The complexities of gerrymandering and its implications for representation are analyzed, alongside a critical look at evolving U.S. foreign policy narratives. They also touch on dietary trends and public health issues, creating an engaging mix of insightful commentary and light banter.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
John's Humorous Mistakes
- John Podhoretz often makes humorous factual errors during the show, like mixing up Henry VIII and Henry II or confusing Harvey Fierstein with Harvey Weinstein.
- The co-hosts usually let these mistakes slide as part of the podcast's casual, lively atmosphere and camaraderie.
Progressivism's Shift Hurts Patriotism
- Modern American progressivism focuses more on fixing flaws than celebrating achieved greatness.
- This shift causes some liberals to struggle with loving America for what it is rather than what it could be.
Restore Trust in Experts
- Engage liberal friends by discussing how to restore trust in experts and institutions.
- This approach avoids tribalism and leads to productive conversations about societal challenges.
