82 | The State and Right: Kant's Metaphysics of Morals
Feb 7, 2024
auto_awesome
Kant's metaphysics of morals explores the role of the state in guaranteeing justice and perpetual peace, but also authorizes the state to kill and denies the right to rebel. The podcast discusses the moral feeling of beheading monarchs, Kant's views on rebellion and revolution, and his admiration for the French Revolution. It also explores topics such as unpleasant smells' impact on moral sense, cryptocurrency, the death penalty, and issues related to rights, immigration, and wealth ownership.
01:01:48
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The state is crucial for upholding justice and ensuring freedom.
Kant's cautious stance towards rebellion raises questions about the tension between individual freedom and the constraints of the state.
Kant's metaphysical understanding of the state leads him to assign moral duties and limitations to it, viewing it as a guardian of justice.
Deep dives
The Importance of the State for Ensuring Freedom
Kant emphasizes the necessity of the state in ensuring freedom and establishing just relationships between individuals. He argues that without the state, justice cannot be upheld and freedom is at risk. The state is viewed as a mechanism to secure the conditions for peace and stability. Kant asserts that rightful force is necessary to prevent the constraints on one's freedom by others. He believes that even in times of war, states should adhere to principles of justice and moral constraints, as violating these principles undermines the legitimacy of the state.
Kant's Ambiguous Stance on Rebellion and Revolution
Kant's position on rebellion and revolution is ambiguous. While he rejects the right to rebel, he acknowledges that rebellions happen and suggests that if a rebellion succeeds, the authority of the new government should be respected. He deems entering into society and leaving behind the state of nature as a duty. Kant's gradualist approach and his emphasis on the necessity of the state can be seen as a response to the radical potential of human action. However, his cautious stance towards rebellion raises questions about the tension between individual freedom and the constraints of the state.
The Fetishization of the State and its Metaphysical Significance
Kant's view of the state extends beyond its practical functions. He regards the state as a metaphysical entity that represents reason and freedom. He equates the state with justice and asserts that without it, human existence loses its value. This metaphysical understanding of the state leads Kant to believe in its absolute importance and inherent goodness. He assigns moral duties and limitations to the state, viewing it as a guardian of justice. However, this metaphysical perspective also leads to some peculiar positions, such as his view on punishments and his rejection of certain societal changes, highlighting the complex relationship between moral theory and political philosophy.
Kant's Disturbed Perspective on the Origin of the State
Kant is disturbed by the historical contingency of the origins of states and believes it is important not to think about the brutal and violent foundations of states. Despite recognizing the genocidal and colonial nature of state origins, Kant idealizes states as bearers of rightful conditions. He aims to preserve stability and allegiance to the state, as he fears acknowledging illegitimate origins could lead to future revolutions. However, this raises questions about justice and the lasting influence of illegitimate origins on the present state. Kant's attempt to suppress curiosity about origins conflicts with Nietzsche's genealogical approach, which highlights the historical contingency and violent nature of state origins. The tension between right and violence arises when it is clear that violence precedes the notion of right, challenging the rational structure Kant tries to establish.
Kant's Defense of the State and the Implications for Rebellion
Kant contends that rebellion seeks the abolition of the rightful condition itself, rather than aiming for a better constitution within the state. He argues that individuals have a duty to enter civil society and form bonds to establish justice and peace. Kant discourages rebellion and justifies this by warning that it would undermine stability and allegiance to the state. He seeks to suppress the idea of rebellion or revolution, fearing it would lead to chaos and an erosion of relationships, possession, and duties. However, his attempt to dissuade rebellion raises questions about the possibility of justifying rebellion in certain circumstances and the tension between preserving the state and the potential for societal progress through insurrection.
In this episode, we dig into the Doctrine of Right in Kant’s Metaphysics of Morals to see what he has to say about the state. Turns out he’s a fan, because the state is what guarantees the possibility of justice and perpetual peace. Nice! But he also thinks that the state should be authorized to kill you. And that you don’t have the right to rebel even if the sovereign is abusing their power. And that you shouldn’t think too hard about the origin of the state. And that human beings are transcendentally disposed to malevolent violence toward each other? So let’s call this a mixed bag, maybe.
leftofphilosophy.com | @leftofphil
References:
Immanuel Kant, The Metaphysics of Morals, trans. Mary Gregor (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1991).
Music:
“Vintage Memories” by Schematist | schematist.bandcamp.com “My Space” by Overu | https://get.slip.stream/KqmvAN
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode