Good One: A Podcast About Jokes John C. Reilly Wants to Keep "Kind & Loving" Comedy Alive
Sep 11, 2025
Join John C. Reilly, acclaimed actor and cabaret performer, as he shares his thoughts on the interplay of comedy and music in storytelling. He discusses his character Mister Romantic and the emotional depth behind performances. The conversation highlights the importance of connection and authenticity in comedy, advocating for a balanced approach in a cynical world. Reilly reflects on his collaboration with Paul Thomas Anderson and the lasting influence of comedy legends, emphasizing the need for kindness and genuine expression in the art form.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Emotional Truth In Satire
- John C. Reilly describes rehearsing the Dylan-style song "Royal Jelly" and becoming unexpectedly moved by its music.
- He and director Jake Kasdan both felt emotional despite the song's satirical lyrics.
Commitment Is The Core Skill
- Reilly argues comedy and drama use the same craft: commit to the reality of the scene.
- In comedy the reality can be more absurd, but sincerity sells the laugh.
Chicago Sparked Mr. Romantic
- Reilly recounts playing Amos Hart in Chicago and making the role genuinely loving rather than purely comic.
- That sincere portrayal inspired his later Mr. Romantic character and cabaret work.