Benjamin Friedman, a full professor in emergency medicine at Montefiore, specializes in headache and back pain management. He dives into the complexities of evaluating acute back pain, emphasizing the need to differentiate benign pain from serious pathology. The discussion covers effective imaging guidelines, the cautious use of NSAIDs and muscle relaxants, and the innovative use of ultrasound in assessments. Friedman shares insights on managing acute pain in emergency settings, highlighting the importance of personalized treatment strategies.
A thorough clinical evaluation is essential to distinguish between benign acute back pain and serious conditions, using red flags and neurological assessments.
While NSAIDs and skeletal muscle relaxants are effective for treatment, non-pharmacologic approaches like yoga and physical therapy can also significantly enhance recovery.
Deep dives
Evaluating Acute Back Pain
When patients present with acute back pain, emergency physicians must focus on a thorough evaluation to differentiate between benign musculoskeletal issues and serious conditions. Key risk factors, such as intravenous drug use and anticoagulant therapy, must be identified as these can lead to severe outcomes like chronic pain or neurologic impairment. A complete history and focused physical exam, emphasizing strength and gait, are essential, and most young, healthy patients will not require extensive evaluations. Factors indicating the need for further testing include the presence of concerning symptoms or abnormal neurologic findings.
Imaging and Treatment Guidelines
For most patients with non-traumatic back pain, imaging like X-rays is unnecessary, particularly in those under 50 without risk factors, as it does not improve outcomes. MRI is only indicated in patients with neurologic deficits or other alarming features, such as infections or tumors. Current evidence supports the use of NSAIDs and skeletal muscle relaxants for managing acute back pain, but acetaminophen and opioids show little to no benefit. While opioids may help in severe cases, they should be prescribed cautiously, keeping in mind the risk of long-term dependence.
Non-Pharmacologic Strategies
Non-pharmacologic approaches to manage back pain can be effective, and patients often benefit from being active participants in their recovery. Techniques such as yoga, stretching, and physical therapy may promote better outcomes, with patients experiencing lower pain levels and improved functional abilities. Additional methods such as spinal mobilization, acupuncture, and cognitive behavioral therapy can also play a role in pain management. Encouraging patients to engage in these activities empowers them to take control of their health and can lead to long-term relief from back pain.
**Please fill out this quick survey to help us develop additional resources for our listeners: Core EM Survey**
Clinical Evaluation:
Primary Goal: Distinguish benign musculoskeletal pain from serious pathology.
Red Flags: Look for indicators of spinal infection, spinal bleed, or space-occupying lesions (e.g., tumors, large herniated discs).
Assessment: A thorough history and neurological exam (strength testing, gait) is essential.
Additional Tools: Use bedside ultrasound for post-void residual assessment in suspected cauda equina syndrome
Imaging Guidelines:
Routine Imaging: Generally not indicated for young, healthy patients without red flags.
ACEP Recommendations: Avoid lumbar X-rays in patients under 50 without risk factors, as they do not change management and may increase costs and ED time.
Advanced Imaging: Reserve MRI for patients with red flags, neurological deficits, or suspected cauda equina syndrome; CRP may be a part of your calculus when evaluating for infectious causes of back pain
Treatment Options:
Evidence-Based First-Line:
NSAIDs offer modest benefit.
Skeletal muscle relaxants can be used but require caution due to side effects.
Ineffective Therapies:
Acetaminophen shows no benefit for back pain.
Steroids are not recommended for non-radicular pain, with only limited benefit in sciatica.
Topical treatments, lidocaine patches, and opioids are not supported by evidence and may pose additional risks.
Alternative and Experimental Interventions:
Nerve Blocks: Current evidence is limited; more research is needed on trigger point injections and erector spinae plane blocks.
Severe Pain Management:
A single opioid dose (preferably codeine or oral morphine) may be considered to facilitate discharge when necessary.
Use diazepam sparingly for immediate mobilization.
Onsite physical therapy in the ED can be beneficial when available.
Preventing Chronic Pain:
Research Focus: Ongoing studies are evaluating whether duloxetine (Cymbalta) can prevent the transition from acute to chronic back pain.
Non-Pharmacologic Measures: Consider spinal mobilization, physical therapy, acupuncture, and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) as adjuncts in management.
Take-Home Points:
Most acute back pain is benign, but watch for red flags like IV drug use, anticoagulation, or neurological symptoms (e.g., weakness, bladder dysfunction) that may indicate serious conditions like spinal infections, bleeds, or cord compression.
Avoid unnecessary lumbar X-rays in young, healthy patients without red flags—MRI is preferred only for those with risk factors, neurological deficits, or suspected cauda equina syndrome.
Use NSAIDs and skeletal muscle relaxants for acute musculoskeletal back pain, as they offer modest benefits. Avoid opioids, acetaminophen, and steroids for non-radicular pain, as they lack evidence.
For severe, uncontrolled pain, consider a single opioid dose (e.g., codeine) or diazepam sparingly
Encourage patients to engage in non-pharmacologic therapies like yoga, massage, or cognitive behavioral therapy to aid recovery and prevent chronic pain.