True Crime Garage The Phantom Killer /// Part 2 /// 888
Nov 26, 2025
A chilling tale unfolds as the Phantom Killer terrorizes Texarkana in 1946, targeting young couples on weekends. Hear about the dramatic escape of Katie Starks and the tragic fate of Virgil Starks during a farmhouse attack. The hosts dive into forensic clues and public panic fueled by sensational newspaper coverage. They explore various suspects, including a confessed killer and an alibi-filled individual. Tensions rise as they debate the motivations and potential identity of the elusive Phantom, leaving listeners captivated by this haunting mystery.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Farmhouse Attack And Barefoot Escape
- Katie Starks fled barefoot across her farmland after being shot twice to reach a neighbor for help. She reached help and Virgil Starks died at the scene, shattering the illusion of safety at home.
Weekend Pattern Suggests Local Hunting Ground
- Most attacks happened on weekend nights and clustered around Texarkana's border geography, implying a local attacker exploiting routines. The pattern suggests the killer targeted weekend lover's lanes where young couples gathered.
Different Caliber Raises Connection Doubts
- Investigators found a flashlight, a .22 bullet, and a bloody footprint at the Starks scene, suggesting different tools than earlier attacks. The .22 raised doubts about whether the farmhouse murder linked to the lover's-lane shootings.
