True Crime Garage
TRUE CRIME GARAGE
True Crime Garage: Your Weekly Dive into Real-Life Mysteries
Grab a chair, crack open a cold one, and join hosts Nic and the Captain for an immersive journey into the world of true crime. True Crime Garage isn’t just a podcast—it’s a deep dive into some of the most fascinating and chilling cases, all delivered with smart storytelling, sharp banter, and a beer in hand.
Each week, Nic and the Captain dissect a new case—from infamous international crimes to haunting hometown mysteries. Whether it’s an unsolved disappearance, a cold case, or the dark psychology behind serial killers, True Crime Garage invites you to think, question, and engage like a true armchair detective.
Why Listen?
Perfect for mystery lovers and true crime enthusiasts, True Crime Garage combines in-depth research, thoughtful discussion, and just the right dose of humor. With a massive archive of episodes, there’s something for everyone—from lifelong fans to new listeners discovering the world of true crime storytelling.
The only rule: don’t litter—and don’t take yourself too seriously. Nic and the Captain sure don’t.
Explore Gripping True Crime Cases
Missing Persons
Maura Murray • Brandon Lawson • Asha Degree • William Tyrrell • Emma Fillipoff • Brian Shaffer • Jaliek Rainwalker • Madeleine McCann • Jennifer Kesse
Unsolved Mysteries
Mitrice Richardson • Kendrick Johnson • JonBenét Ramsey • The Delphi Murders • O.J. Simpson • The Tylenol Murders • Elisa Lam • Kris Kremers & Lisanne Froon • The West Memphis Three • Amy Mihaljevic
Infamous Serial Killers
The Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) • Zodiac Killer • Ted Bundy • Ivan Milat (The Backpacker Killer) • BTK (Dennis Rader) • John Wayne Gacy • Jeffrey Dahmer • Edmund Kemper • Ed Gein
Solved Cases
Chris Watts • The Unabomber • John Lennon • Scott Peterson • Son of Sam • Columbine • Sidney Teerhuis-Moar (Room 309) • Kenneka Jenkins • Rae Carruth
Pour yourself a drink and join the garage each week—where the cases are cold, the stories are hot, and the conversation never ends.
Grab a chair, crack open a cold one, and join hosts Nic and the Captain for an immersive journey into the world of true crime. True Crime Garage isn’t just a podcast—it’s a deep dive into some of the most fascinating and chilling cases, all delivered with smart storytelling, sharp banter, and a beer in hand.
Each week, Nic and the Captain dissect a new case—from infamous international crimes to haunting hometown mysteries. Whether it’s an unsolved disappearance, a cold case, or the dark psychology behind serial killers, True Crime Garage invites you to think, question, and engage like a true armchair detective.
Why Listen?
Perfect for mystery lovers and true crime enthusiasts, True Crime Garage combines in-depth research, thoughtful discussion, and just the right dose of humor. With a massive archive of episodes, there’s something for everyone—from lifelong fans to new listeners discovering the world of true crime storytelling.
The only rule: don’t litter—and don’t take yourself too seriously. Nic and the Captain sure don’t.
Explore Gripping True Crime Cases
Missing Persons
Maura Murray • Brandon Lawson • Asha Degree • William Tyrrell • Emma Fillipoff • Brian Shaffer • Jaliek Rainwalker • Madeleine McCann • Jennifer Kesse
Unsolved Mysteries
Mitrice Richardson • Kendrick Johnson • JonBenét Ramsey • The Delphi Murders • O.J. Simpson • The Tylenol Murders • Elisa Lam • Kris Kremers & Lisanne Froon • The West Memphis Three • Amy Mihaljevic
Infamous Serial Killers
The Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) • Zodiac Killer • Ted Bundy • Ivan Milat (The Backpacker Killer) • BTK (Dennis Rader) • John Wayne Gacy • Jeffrey Dahmer • Edmund Kemper • Ed Gein
Solved Cases
Chris Watts • The Unabomber • John Lennon • Scott Peterson • Son of Sam • Columbine • Sidney Teerhuis-Moar (Room 309) • Kenneka Jenkins • Rae Carruth
Pour yourself a drink and join the garage each week—where the cases are cold, the stories are hot, and the conversation never ends.
Episodes
Mentioned books
Dec 2, 2025 • 45min
Kierra Coles /// Part 2
The hosts dive deep into the mysterious case of Kierra Coles, a USPS employee who vanished in 2018. They discuss her last moments, raising alarming questions about her boyfriend's involvement and the investigation's chilling stagnation. Surveillance footage reveals new clues, while theories of foul play and cover-ups unfold. The episode highlights growing family frustrations, urges for public pressure, and the crucial need for renewed investigation efforts. With considerable reward incentives still in place, hope remains for new leads.
Dec 2, 2025 • 56min
Kierra Coles /// Part 1
In this gripping discussion, the hosts dive into the mysterious disappearance of Kierra Coles, a USPS employee who vanished in 2018. They explore Kierra's life, her last known contacts, and the unsettling circumstances surrounding her missed work call. The investigation reveals oddities in her apartment and the enigmatic presence of a USPS-clad woman on surveillance footage. Speculation about a staged decoy raises eyebrows, while Kierra's boyfriend's conflicting statements add to the intrigue. Family efforts to find her reveal layers of frustration and desperation.
Nov 26, 2025 • 1h 10min
The Phantom Killer /// Part 2 /// 888
A chilling tale unfolds as the Phantom Killer terrorizes Texarkana in 1946, targeting young couples on weekends. Hear about the dramatic escape of Katie Starks and the tragic fate of Virgil Starks during a farmhouse attack. The hosts dive into forensic clues and public panic fueled by sensational newspaper coverage. They explore various suspects, including a confessed killer and an alibi-filled individual. Tensions rise as they debate the motivations and potential identity of the elusive Phantom, leaving listeners captivated by this haunting mystery.
Nov 26, 2025 • 55min
The Phantom Killer /// Part 1 /// 887
In a chilling tale, the story of the Phantom Killer unfolds, haunting Texarkana since 1946. Young couples faced a terrifying attacker under the moonlight, leading to a series of brutal assaults and murders. Key details emerge about the victims, their harrowing experiences, and the social context impacting investigations. The mystery deepens with debates on whether earlier assaults were linked to the murders, and patterns hint at a calculated predator. As fear grips the town, the legend of the Phantom Killer lives on.
Nov 19, 2025 • 1h 19min
Ellen Greenberg ////// 886
Sheryl "Mac" McCollum, a crime analyst and founder of the Cold Case Investigative Research Institute, dives deep into the mysterious death of Ellen Greenberg. Despite sustaining 20 knife wounds, her death was labeled a suicide, sparking outrage from her parents. Sheryl highlights red flags in the 911 call, scrutinizes the improbable suicide conclusion given the injuries, and critiques investigation failures. She explores forensic evidence, challenges the fiancé's alibi, and emphasizes the need for thorough evidence collection in unraveling this tragic case.
Nov 12, 2025 • 52min
Robin Abrams /// Part 2 /// 885
Delve into the mysterious case of Robin Abrams, who disappeared in 1990 without a trace. Explore the involvement of law enforcement, conflicts of interest, and the frustratingly limited investigative progress. Eyewitness accounts and legal battles over evidence raise questions, while forensic searches yield no results. Family frustration grows as media coverage prompts new theories about a possible cover-up. Discover the ongoing fight for justice as leads and DNA comparisons continue to unfold.
Nov 12, 2025 • 45min
Robin Abrams /// Part 1 /// 884
The disappearance of former sheriff's deputy Robin Abrams is shrouded in mystery. A series of eerie events, including the discovery of her abandoned car and purse, raise suspicion of foul play. The podcast dives into Robin's background, her troubling relationship with Tony Marquez, and her previous harassment claims against the sheriff's office. The investigation is now under the Illinois State Police, sparked by a federal lawsuit that intensifies the quest for answers. The hosts keep listeners engaged with updates on legal proceedings and emphasize the ongoing search for tips.
Nov 5, 2025 • 52min
Dark Side of the Mountain /// Part 2 /// 883
Dark Side of the Mountain /// Part 2 /// 883Part 2 of 2 www.TrueCrimeGarage.comTwo men - each possibly grappling with his own version of a mid-life crisis - vanish 10 months apart from the same, tiny town in the Colorado Rockies under eerily similar circumstances. In September of 1987, a 47-year-old man and his faithful dog vanished from the near-ghost town of Silver Plume, Colorado. Months later in August 1988 another man, staring down the barrel of 50 years of age, retraced the missing man’s steps to investigate the mystery - and he too - disappeared. This is the true story of Tom Young who went missing on the dark side of the mountain, and too the story of Keith Reinhard who may have vanished forever. Beer of the Week - Wanderlust IPA by Breakside BreweryGarage Grade - 4 and a half bottle caps out of 5 More True Crime Garage can be found on Patreon and Apple subscriptions with our show - Off The Record. Catch dozens of episodes of Off The Record plus a couple of Bonus episodes and our first 50 when you sign up today. True Crime Garage merchandise is available on our website’s store page. Follow the show on X and Insta @TrueCrimeGarage / Follow Nic on X @TCGNIC / Follow The Captain on X @TCGCaptain Thanks for listening and thanks for telling a friend. Be good, be kind, and don’t litter! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Nov 5, 2025 • 50min
Dark Side of the Mountain /// Part 1 /// 882
In a tiny town in the Colorado Rockies, two men vanish under mysterious circumstances a decade apart. Tom Young disappears with his dog in 1987, and in 1988, Keith Reinhard retraces his footsteps only to vanish too. As they explore the intriguing disappearances, doubts surface about Tom's death, previously ruled a suicide. Keith's obsession with Tom's story inspires a novel, leading him deeper into the enigma before he hikes Pendleton Peak, never to return. The dark side of Silver Plume reveals secrets no one expected.
Oct 29, 2025 • 51min
A Killer Halloween /// Part 2 /// 881
A Killer Halloween /// Part 2 /// 881Part 2 of 2 www.TrueCrimeGarage.comWelcome into the terrifying Garage of horrors. It’s an old and dark structure filled with stories of murder and mayhem. This week we explore this great country by taking a “killer tour” of sorts. On tap we have tales of killers like John Wayne Gacy, Ed Gein and even more killers from different cities that are sure to have you looking over your shoulder this Halloween. Beer of the Week - Graffiti Highway double IPA by Troegs Independent BrewingGarage Grade - 4 and a quarter bottle caps out of 5 LIMITED EDITION 2025 HALLOWEEN shirts and other great True Crime Garage swag is available on our website’s “MERCH" page.More True Crime Garage can be found on Patreon and Apple subscriptions with our show - Off The Record. Dozens of episodes of Off The Record plus a couple of Bonus episodes and our first 50 when you sign up today. Thanks for listening and thanks for telling a friend. Be good, be kind, and don’t litter! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
