In this engaging discussion, Andy Rudalevich, a Bowdoin College professor specializing in the executive branch, unpacks the evolving nature of presidential power. He explores the ambiguous powers outlined by the Constitution and traces their expansion through historical crises. Notably, Rudalevich delves into the impact of the Cold War, the 9/11 attacks, and recent unilateral actions like student loan forgiveness. He emphasizes the delicate balance between executive authority and democratic oversight, shedding light on the complexities of the presidency today.
The framers of the U.S. Constitution intentionally left presidential powers vague to allow flexibility and adaptation to changing governance needs.
Historical crises have repeatedly led to significant expansions of presidential authority, illustrating the tension between effective leadership and potential tyranny.
Deep dives
The Birth of the Executive Branch
The Constitutional Convention of 1787 marked a pivotal moment in American history as the framers grappled with the question of how much power to grant the executive branch. Initially, the government was ineffective, struggling to manage post-Revolutionary War challenges, leading to concerns about potential tyranny. Amid this chaos, the framers recognized the need for a centralized authority to enforce laws, yet they were wary of establishing a strong monarchy-like figure. The eventual solution was to create an executive branch led by a president, as codified in Article II of the U.S. Constitution, while ensuring that the power granted remained balanced and constrained.
Defining Presidential Power
The framers of the Constitution intentionally left the powers of the presidency vague, allowing for broad interpretation and growth of executive authority. Key aspects of presidential power, such as the roles of commander-in-chief and the ability to negotiate treaties, were established alongside the requirement for Senate approval, creating a system of checks and balances. Despite these provisions, the flexibility of Article II facilitated the expansion of presidential powers, causing concerns among some founders about potential executive overreach. Historical examples, such as Edmund Randolph's caution against a developing monarchy, highlighted the tension between effective governance and the avoidance of tyranny.
The Transformation to Modern Presidency
The presidency evolved significantly over the first 150 years, especially during times of crisis when presidents expanded their powers. George Washington's collaborative approach with Congress contrasted sharply with later presidents, like Abraham Lincoln and Franklin Roosevelt, who exercised greater unilateral authority in response to national challenges. Roosevelt's introduction of a comprehensive legislative program and his innovative communication strategies transformed the presidency into a central power, effectively reshaping its role in American governance. His administration's actions during the Great Depression exemplified how a crisis can increase executive authority, with Roosevelt wielding significant power previously considered out of reach for the presidency.
The Imperial Presidency and Its Legacy
The concept of the 'imperial presidency' emerged prominently during Richard Nixon's administration as he expanded executive power beyond constitutional bounds, particularly in matters of war and national security. Notable actions included the unauthorized invasion of Cambodia and the use of federal agencies to undermine accountability, culminating in the Watergate scandal. This erosion of checks and balances led to a bipartisan pushback from Congress, resulting in legislation aimed at curtailing presidential overreach. Subsequent presidencies have navigated this complex landscape, often building on the precedents set by their predecessors, raising ongoing concerns about the balance of power within the U.S. government.
What can and can't the president do — and how do we know? The framers of the U.S. Constitution left the powers of the executive branch powers deliberately vague, and in doing so opened the door for every president to decide how much power they could claim. Over time, that's become quite a lot. This episode originally ran in 2020 and has been updated with new material.
To access bonus episodes and listen to Throughline sponsor-free, subscribe to Throughline+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/throughline.