The podcast addresses the challenge of effectively discussing gender issues with those who have different perspectives, emphasizing the importance of owning mistakes and building relationships. It explores the distinction between gender stereotypes and identity, and highlights the impact of parenting on a child's identity formation. The podcast also emphasizes the power of collaboration and communion in addressing gender issues and discusses the potential risks faced by therapists in this field.
Engaging in relational conversations is important when discussing gender issues, focusing on ongoing communication and understanding rather than quick comments or social media platforms.
Acknowledging and owning mistakes made within the Church and Catholic culture regarding gender allows for growth, correction of errors, and separating teachings from their manifestation in real-life experiences.
Deep dives
Engaging the Conversation
When discussing gender issues, it is important to engage in relational conversations rather than relying on social media platforms. These conversations should take place within the context of a relationship, allowing for ongoing communication and understanding. It is not about making quick comments or stating short phrases to make a point, but rather about having open and curious discussions. This requires listening and being present, creating space for others to be heard and expressing their experiences and perspectives.
Acknowledging Mistakes
As Catholics, it is crucial to acknowledge and own the mistakes made within the Church and Catholic culture when it comes to understanding gender. This does not question the truth and magisterial teachings of the Church, but rather recognizes that the way these teachings have been integrated and applied in the cultural context may have contributed to confusion and misinterpretation. By separating the teachings from their manifestation in real-life experiences, it becomes possible to own our part in perpetuating errors and work towards correcting them.
Distinguishing Stereotypes from Identity
It is important to understand the distinction between stereotypes and identity when discussing gender. Stereotypes associate certain behaviors and characteristics with gender, while identity goes beyond simplistic categorizations. By breaking apart these two concepts, a more accurate and precise conversation about gender can take place, focusing on the multi-faceted nature of individual experiences. This approach avoids conflating stereotypes with identity and allows for a fuller understanding of what it means to be a man or a woman.
Developmental Process and Parts Theory
Recognizing the developmental phases of becoming human is essential in understanding gender. From conception, individuals develop through different stages, forming their sense of self and identity. These phases involve learning and integrating various parts of our psyche, acquired through relationships and modeling from parents. By embracing the complexity of human development and the existence of different parts within ourselves, we can better comprehend the diversity of gender experiences and open up more empathetic and validating conversations.
Welcome to Episode 153 of the Being Human Podcast: How to Talk About Gender Issues
How do we talk about gender issues to people who don’t necessarily share the same views? How can we make sense of the gender ideologies and confusion so prevalent in our culture today? In this week’s episode, Dr. Greg shares important principles to remember when engaging others in conversation on this sensitive topic.
Discussed in the episode:
How do we communicate a Catholic perspective on gender ideology to those who may not share the same perspective?
The meaning and importance of owning our mistakes as a Church;
Entering into relationship with another as a necessary prerequisite to evangelizing with love;
Why it’s essential to recognize the distinction between gender stereotypes and gender identity;
The importance of understanding that each person has different parts and experiences within themselves;
How communion can be possible in the midst of varying parts and perspectives;
Seeing the developmental stages starting from conception as a gradual becoming more of who God calls us to be;
Why modeling from the same-sex parent and complementarity from the opposite-sex parent significantly impacts the formation of a child’s identity.
Become a member of the Integrated Life Community to get access to every course Dr. Greg has created, plus the opportunity to participate in Integrated LIVE’s - weekly, Mentor hosted Q&As covering topics like boundaries, communication, trauma, forgiveness, and more!
Contact us! Have a topic or a question you would like Dr. Greg to address on the podcast? Want to give some feedback about this episode? Email us at beinghuman@catholicpsych.com - we would love to hear from you!
Rate, review, and subscribe
Please help us in our mission to integrate the Faith with Psychology by hitting subscribe and also sharing this podcast with your friends.
Please consider rating or leaving a review of our show. It helps us reach other Catholics just like you who want to become more integrated, whole, and happy human beings.
For Apple podcasts, click here, scroll to the bottom, tap to rate 5 stars, and choose “write a review.” Then type your sincere thoughts about the show!