Shakespeare's stories aren't boring — we are teaching them wrong way
Oct 1, 2024
auto_awesome
Fintan O'Toole, an acclaimed Irish journalist and author, dives into the profound misconceptions surrounding Shakespeare's works, shaped by Victorian interpretations. He reveals how oversimplified teachings strip the complexity and humor from Shakespeare's characters. The conversation contrasts the rich engagement of early encounters with the disconnection experienced in traditional classrooms. O'Toole also examines psychological depths in plays like 'Macbeth' and critiques the 19th-century's moralistic view, advocating for a deeper appreciation of the playwright’s intricate narratives.
Shakespeare's plays are often oversimplified in education, stripping away their complex characters and dynamic narratives, making them appear uninteresting.
Fintan O'Toole emphasizes that understanding Shakespeare’s exploration of morality and power can evoke deep engagement and resonance with modern audiences.
Deep dives
Shakespeare's Misrepresentation
Shakespeare's plays are often misrepresented in educational contexts, reducing their complexity to mere moral lessons or fatal flaws of the characters. This oversimplification relegates the nuanced and dynamic nature of the characters to forgettable tropes. The discussion highlights how Hamlet's procrastination, Othello's rashness, and Macbeth’s ambition are frequently used to frame the narrative, but that approach strips away the rich, multifaceted drama Shakespeare intended. By framing these plays through a simplistic lens, the engaging and tragic essence of Shakespeare’s work is rendered boring and uninteresting.
The Psychological Depth of Shakespeare's Characters
The podcast explores how Shakespeare dives deep into the psychological processes of his characters, making them relatable despite their moral failings. For instance, in Macbeth, the character grapples with the consequences of his violent ambition, yet the audience can't help but feel a strange identification with his plight. This intricate portrayal compels viewers to explore complex themes of morality, identity, and the human experience rather than offering simple resolutions or moral judgments. In contrast to the common teaching methods, this understanding fosters a deeper engagement with the text and its characters, transcending traditional interpretations.
The Ambiguity of Power and Morality
Shakespeare's exploration of power and its consequences reveals the ambiguity and unpredictability of moral choice. In King Lear, the narrative challenges the idea of clear rewards and punishments, culminating in devastating moments that evoke empathic responses towards characters who are morally ambiguous. This complexity leads to profound reflections on authority and justice, resonating with audiences' real-life experiences. Shakespeare's subversion of traditional morality, particularly in the portrayal of tragic figures, invites audiences to grapple with the messiness inherent in humanity and the outcomes of power struggles.
An Irish Perspective on Shakespeare
The speaker reflects on how their Irish background influences their interpretation of Shakespeare's work, providing a unique distance from typical English-centric perceptions. This perspective allows for a more critical engagement with Shakespeare’s plays, recognizing them as products of a messy, transitional world rather than a sanitized ideal of moral lessons. The connection to contemporary societal challenges mirrors the complexities faced in Shakespeare's narratives, allowing modern audiences to draw parallels between the playwright's themes and current socio-political dynamics. Consequently, this approach emphasizes the universality and relevance of Shakespeare's insights into human nature and societal structures.
Irish journalist and author, Fintan O'Toole on how the Victorians changed the meaning of Shakespeare's plays, and how we can bring them back to life.
Fintan O'Toole is an Irish journalist and author who writes on politics and history for the New York Review of Books and the Irish Times.
He wants to change the way we think about Shakespeare's plays, because the way many of us are introduced to Shakespeare is wrong and boring.
Fintan says Shakespeare’s work is wrongly presented as a delivery system for simple moral instruction — a hangover from the Victorian era, which wanted to turn Shakespeare into a form of "mental muesli".
According to Fintan, the genius of Shakespeare is that his characters keep escaping narrow moral categories, just as people do in real life.
This episode of Conversations deals with Shakespeare's epic plays, life, death, betrayal, history, kings, royalty, motherhood, fatherhood, grief, life processes, making meaning of life and morality, Othello, Hamlet, Romeo and Juliet.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode