Exploring the Clash: Traditional Philosophy vs. Dispositional Approaches in Understanding Pain and Human Complexity
Aug 13, 2023
auto_awesome
Join us on a journey to understand pain, human complexities, and the intersection of critical thinking and evidence-based practice, featuring guest Roger Kerry, an accomplished scholar. Delve into the irony of simplifying variables in science, explore reliance on research in healthcare, examine Hume's theory of causation, understand dispositionalism, recognize the power of stories in medicine, and uncover Richard Feynman's relevance to manual therapy.
Embracing a dispositional perspective can help clinicians better understand and respond to the individual nature of pain.
Reconceptualizing causation through dispositionalism can enhance our understanding of the unique dispositions and contexts of individuals, leading to more patient-centered care.
Deep dives
Roger Carey's Journey into Philosophy of Science
Roger Carey shares his early interest in philosophy of science and how it developed throughout his professional career. He highlights the tension between traditional philosophy of science and dispositional approaches that consider unique individuals and causation beyond strict empirical interpretations. This understanding of dispositionalism has valuable implications for clinicians in practice as they navigate the complexity of pain conditions and the linear approach of finding and fixing. By embracing a dispositional perspective, clinicians can better understand and respond to the individual nature of pain.
The Paradoxes of Science and Causation
Roger delves into the paradoxes of science and causation, addressing the limits of traditional scientific views of regularity and control groups. He explores the relationship between science and the complexity of the real world, emphasizing the importance of understanding complexity within healthcare. While randomized controlled trials and evidence-based practice provide guidance, they do not fully capture the complexity of individuals' experiences and responses to interventions. Roger proposes that reconceptualizing causation through dispositionalism can enhance our understanding of the unique dispositions and contexts of individuals, leading to more patient-centered care.
Reconciling Evidence-Based Practice with Complexity
Roger discusses how evidence-based practice can be reconciled with the complexity inherent in healthcare. He emphasizes the need for good clinical reasoning to navigate the complexities of patient care. While evidence-based practice provides valuable guidance, it should not overshadow the importance of understanding the unique nature of each patient. Roger suggests a shift in mindset, focusing on developing clinical reasoning skills that embrace complexity and uncertainty. This approach allows clinicians to adapt and respond effectively to individual patients, while still utilizing evidence and guidelines as part of the decision-making process.
Teaching clinicians to navigate complexity
Roger reflects on the challenge of teaching clinicians to navigate complexity and uncertainty in patient care. He highlights the importance of clinical reasoning skills and how they can help clinicians embrace discomfort and uncertainty. While there is a need to provide some procedural guidance and knowledge in education, there should also be a focus on teaching students to work with complex situations and adapt their approaches based on individual patient needs. By developing clinical reasoning abilities and a deeper understanding of patients, clinicians can better address the unique complexities they encounter in clinical practice.
š§ Welcome to a Captivating Exploration of Critical Thinking, Philosophy, Evidence-Based Practice, and Physical Therapy! š§ š
Tune in to our thought-provoking podcast episode as we delve into the intriguing clash between traditional philosophies of science and the dispositional approach. Join us on a journey to understand pain, human complexities, and the intersection of critical thinking and evidence-based practice, featuring our guest, Roger Kerry, an accomplished scholar in this field.
šļø In this episode: Roger shares his unique insights that illuminate the interplay between critical thinking, philosophy, and evidence-based practice. Discover how a serendipitous encounter and transformative books ignited his journey to navigate profound concepts, leading him to pursue his PhD in this area.
š” Key Points:
Questioning Paradoxes in Science: Delve into the irony of simplifying variables and its potential to detach us from the true reality.
Pragmatic Randomized Controlled Trials: Explore the reliance of healthcare practitioners on research and its impact on guideline development.
Philosophical Insights: Examine Hume's theory of causation and the nuanced use of randomization for establishing causality.
Dispositionalism and Individuality: Understand how this approach balances professional demands and clinical guidelines.
Narrative-Based Medicine: Recognize the power of stories in enhancing patient understanding.
Richard Feynman's Theories: Uncover their relevance to manual therapy and context-specific variables in treatments.
š Immerse yourself in the world of critical thinking, philosophy, evidence-based practice, and physical therapy as we challenge conventional notions and offer a fresh perspective on these intricate topics.
š§ Subscribe now to embark on a journey of intellectual stimulation and curiosity through our engaging podcast series!
********************************************************************* šø - Follow us on Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/modernpaincare/
š¦ - Follow us on Twitter - https://www.twitter.com/modernpaincare/
šļø - Listen to our Podcast - https://www.modernpaincare.com
____________________________________ Modern Pain Care is a company dedicated to spreading evidence-based and person-centered information about pain, prevention, and overall fitness and wellness
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode