Join Dr. Eve MacDonald, an expert on ancient Mediterranean history, as she unpacks the dramatic fall of Carthage in 146 BC. The discussion dives into Rome’s military strategies and the brutal sieges during the Punic Wars, shedding light on the complexities often lost in Roman narratives. MacDonald also highlights Carthage's resilience, its architectural grandeur, and the emotional aftermath of its destruction, all while reflecting on the far-reaching implications of Carthage's end in shaping future civilizations.
The siege of Carthage in 146 BC exemplified brutal urban warfare, showcasing the determination of both Roman forces and Carthaginian defenders.
Cato the Elder's fervent campaign against Carthage highlighted the deep political motivations and historical animosities driving Roman imperial ambitions.
The fall of Carthage not only led to its physical destruction but also symbolized the cultural loss and complex legacy intertwined with Roman history.
Deep dives
The Fall of Carthage: A Historical Overview
The story of the fall of Carthage in 146 BC is marked by brutal urban warfare as Roman soldiers relentlessly besieged the city, intent on eradicating its existence. Carthage, located in present-day Tunisia, was a thriving Mediterranean power until the Romans decided to crush it decisively in the Third Punic War. Despite a long-standing peace after the Second Punic War, the Romans, driven by figures like Cato the Elder, sought to eliminate Carthage as a threat. The siege culminated in a fierce struggle, with Carthaginian defenders making a desperate last stand at the Bursa Hill as their city burned around them.
Cato the Elder's Role in the Conflict
Cato the Elder emerged as a significant figure advocating for the destruction of Carthage, famously proclaiming, 'Carthago delenda est' (Carthage must be destroyed) in the Roman Senate. His shock at witnessing Carthage's prosperity in 153 BC fueled his campaign, reflecting fears within Rome of a resurgence of the city. This relentless push against Carthage highlights the tension in the Roman Senate, where diverse opinions about the fate of Carthage played out. Cato’s obsession with Carthage reveals both a political strategy to secure Roman hegemony and a deep-seated animosity toward a historical rival.
Military Strategy and the Siege
The siege of Carthage was marked by intense military strategy and resilience from both the Romans and the Carthaginians. As Roman forces encircled the city in 149 BC, they faced not only physical fortifications but also a determined population committed to defending their homeland. The fighting involved a combination of land and naval tactics, with Carthage mobilizing its citizens, including women and children, to fortify their defenses and produce weapons. Ultimately, the Romans succeeded through persistent assaults and breaches in the city walls, leading to horrific violence as they advanced through the packed streets.
The Desperate Last Stand
As the Romans penetrated further into the city, Carthaginian leaders retreated to the Bursa Hill, where they made their final stand. The desperation was palpable as they fought fiercely for their culture and identity, with some opting for suicide rather than capture. A poignant moment arises with the wife of Hasdrubal, who berates her husband for his cowardice before taking her own life, encompassing the emotional and cultural tragedy of their defeat. This last stand symbolizes the cruelty of the conflict, where defeat meant not only a loss of territory but also the annihilation of a civilization's legacy.
Aftermath and Historical Legacy
Following the conquest, Romans celebrated their victory over Carthage, leading to the city's complete destruction and a symbolic curse placed upon its ruins. The narrative spread that the land was 'sown with salt,' although this metaphorical representation speaks more to the desire to eradicate any memory of Carthage. However, this act of destruction did not end Carthage's tale; the site would eventually be rebuilt as a Roman city, establishing a complex legacy intertwined with both civilizations' histories. Archaeological evidence continues to reveal layers of this destruction, offering insights into the profound impacts of Roman imperial ambitions on the ancient world.
It’s 146 BC. Fire rises high over the North African coast. The once-thriving port city of Carthage is burning. Thousands of Roman soldiers have breached the defences and swarmed into the city, intent on wiping this city from the face of the earth. This is the fall of Carthage.
Tristan Hughes is joined by Dr Eve MacDonald to plot the steps that lead to the Romans ruthlessly crushing this ancient Mediterranean power, once and for all. In the infamous words of the Roman statesman Cato the Elder; ‘Carthago Delenda Est’ - Carthage Must be Destroyed’
Presented by Tristan Hughes. Edited and produced by Joseph Knight, the senior producer is Anne-Marie Luff.
The Ancients is a History Hit podcast.
Enjoy unlimited access to award-winning original TV documentaries that are released weekly and AD-FREE podcasts. Sign upHERE for 50% off your first 3 months using code ‘ANCIENTS’. https://historyhit.com/subscription