#91 Why The Church Can’t Ordain Women - Joe Heschmeyer
Jul 30, 2024
auto_awesome
Joe Heschmeyer, a Catholic expert on female ordination, tackles the controversial issue of why the Church cannot ordain women as priests. He delves into the theological foundations of the male-only priesthood, referencing John Paul II's key teachings. The discussion reveals how concepts of fatherhood and divine revelation shape this doctrine. Through a mix of historical context and modern implications, Heschmeyer clarifies common misconceptions and provides deeper insight into the Church's stance on priesthood.
The Catholic Church holds that only men can be ordained as priests due to the theological implications of Jesus' choice of male apostles.
Ordination is seen as a vocation embodying fatherhood, highlighting distinct yet equally significant roles for men and women in the Church.
Deep dives
The Church's Teaching on Priesthood
The Catholic Church maintains that priestly ordination is reserved solely for men, a stance reaffirmed by John Paul II. He emphasized that this teaching is rooted in a longstanding tradition and holds a dogmatic status rather than being merely a matter of discipline. The Church cannot change this doctrine without contradicting its identity as the Church of Jesus Christ, as doing so would invalidate two millennia of tradition. Therefore, it is essential for Catholics to accept the belief that the Church lacks the authority to ordain women as priests.
Jesus' Choice and Its Implications
The argument centers on Jesus' deliberate choice to select only men as his apostles, which is perceived as a binding practice for the priesthood. Critics argue that Jesus' decision resulted from the cultural norms of his time and not a restriction on women's roles within the Church. However, this perspective overlooks Jesus' radical inclusivity, as he frequently included women in his ministry, indicating that his choice was intentional and maintained for a reason. The fact that he did not ordain women even while engaging with them highlights the unique nature of priesthood that transcends cultural limitations.
The Nature of Priesthood as Vocation
The male-only priesthood is viewed not merely as an occupational role, but as a vocation that embodies fatherhood, which is inherently tied to masculinity. This distinction suggests that the priesthood involves relational and vocational elements, setting it apart from typical jobs that can be occupied by anyone qualified. Comparing the priesthood to motherhood underscores that men and women are called to different but equally significant roles within the Church. Ultimately, the priest's role as a representative of God goes beyond qualifications, as it ties into core theological concepts about God's nature and how He reveals Himself.