The podcast discusses the controversial parking meter leasing deal in Chicago, the negative impacts of privatizing parking meters, the trade-off between parking and housing, the impact of the deal on electric vehicles, and the challenges of parking and appreciating green spaces.
The Chicago parking meter deal highlights the importance of thorough evaluation and public input before entering into novel privatization agreements.
Rethinking parking policies and transitioning to alternative modes of transportation is essential in creating sustainable and livable cities.
Deep dives
The Chicago Parking Meter Privatization
Chicago sold its parking meters to a Morgan Stanley-led consortium, resulting in skyrocketing parking fees and dissatisfaction among residents. The deal, which lacked transparency, didn't consider the long-term financial implications for the city. It also restricted the city's ability to implement parking policies and invest in public services. The privatization of parking meters highlights the importance of thorough evaluation and public input before entering into novel privatization agreements.
The Negative Consequences of Excessive Parking
Parking minimums and underpriced parking create numerous problems, such as traffic congestion, increased pollution, and lost space for affordable housing and urban amenities. American cities, inspired by the suburban model, overbuilt parking, leading to an imbalance between demand and supply. Rethinking parking policies and transitioning to alternative modes of transportation, such as electric vehicles, will be essential in creating sustainable and livable cities.
The Impact of Electric Vehicles on Parking
The rise of electric vehicles introduces new challenges to parking infrastructure. The availability of residential charging options will be critical in enabling widespread adoption of electric vehicles. Multifamily buildings and street parking areas need to be equipped with adequate charging infrastructure to support the transition to electric transportation. Finding innovative solutions to ensure charging accessibility without sacrificing urban space is crucial for reducing emissions and improving air quality.
Lessons from the Chicago Parking Meter Fiasco
The Chicago parking meter deal serves as a cautionary tale about hasty privatization agreements and inadequate due diligence. Cities should carefully evaluate the long-term consequences and seek public input before entering into such agreements. Furthermore, it is essential to consider the value of parking and its potential to fund public services and infrastructure. Balancing the interests of the public, private entities, and urban development is crucial for creating equitable and sustainable cities.
Cautionary Book Club:When Morgan Stanley offered to lease Chicago's parking meters for the princely sum of $1 billion, the City Council were convinced that they had struck gold. They hastily signed the deal. But they soon learnt that they hadn't just traded away parking revenue - they had traded away the streets themselves...
In this hybrid episode of Cautionary Tales, Tim Harford first tells the story of the Chicago parking metres fiasco of 2008. In the second half, Tim is joined by Henry Grabar, author of Paved Paradise, to discuss the lessons we can glean from Chicago's deal with Wall Street, and why parking is such an emotive issue for so many.