The Words Matter Podcast with Oliver Thomson cover image

The Words Matter Podcast with Oliver Thomson

Truth and plausibility - How should we engage with nonsensical claims made by colleagues? With Jack Chew and Prof. Dave Newell

Aug 19, 2022
Physical therapist Jack Chew and Professor Dave Newell join the host to discuss engaging with nonsensical claims made by colleagues. They explore the challenges of calling out false claims on social media, the risks of using homeopathy in pediatric cancer treatment, and the difficulty of explaining complex concepts to patients. They emphasize skepticism, critical thinking, and the importance of open dialogue in evaluating fringe beliefs.
01:21:03

Podcast summary created with Snipd AI

Quick takeaways

  • Careful consideration of the consequences and potential harm that can arise from implausible claims in healthcare is crucial, especially when they lead patients to reject evidence-based care.
  • Critically evaluating claims for biological plausibility is essential, as certain claims may resonate with patients despite appearing implausible due to perceived connections between anatomical structures and bodily systems.

Deep dives

The Importance of Truth Claims and Harm

The focus of this podcast episode is on the importance of truth claims and the potential harm that can arise from holding and promoting implausible beliefs. The hosts discuss how certain claims made by healthcare professionals on social media can be called out and the ethical obligations involved. They emphasize the need for careful consideration of the consequences and potential harm that can arise from these claims, especially when they lead patients to reject evidence-based care. The conversation explores the line between criticism and ridicule, with a recognition that different goals and contexts can influence the appropriate response. It highlights the significance of biological plausibility and the importance of critically evaluating claims before embracing or promoting them.

Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts

Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
App store bannerPlay store banner