Paid to Care: When Class, Power, and Caregiving Collide
Jan 14, 2025
auto_awesome
In this discussion, Koa Beck, a writer and foster parent, reveals the intricate dynamics of foster care and its striking parallels to nannying. She shares Delores's journey as a Jamaican nanny in NYC, navigating cultural nuances and parental expectations. The conversation dives into the complexities of class and power in caregiving, touching on the emotional bonds formed between caregivers and the families they serve. Additionally, Koa highlights the significance of community support for those involved in care work, particularly in the face of challenges like multiple sclerosis.
The podcast explores the emotional complexities of caregiving, highlighting the intertwining joys and challenges faced by caregivers in their roles.
It delves into the evolving power dynamics in caregiving relationships, particularly the influence caregivers have on parenting approaches and emotional well-being.
Deep dives
Voices from Caregivers
The podcast emphasizes the emotional complexity of caregiving work, highlighting the intimate and often overwhelming nature of the role. Many caregivers express the profound joys and challenges they experience, which are deeply intertwined with their personal lives. These shared stories reveal how caregivers navigate their relationships with those they care for, discussing dynamics that can include feelings of love, responsibility, and sometimes resentment. The episode showcases the voices of caregivers through voice memos, providing a powerful glimpse into their daily realities and the emotional toll caregiving can take.
Changing Relationships in Caregiving
The power dynamics within caregiving relationships are examined, particularly how they have evolved over time. Caregivers often find themselves guiding parents in their child-rearing philosophies, suggesting that an established caregiver may have a significant role in shaping the experience for both child and parent. This can lead to mixed feelings among caregivers who may sense the expectations placed upon them. The impact of shifts in parenting styles, particularly influenced by technology, alters these relationships significantly and complicates caregiving roles.
The Complexities of Foster Care
Foster care is presented as a unique form of paid caregiving where parents work under the guidance of government entities. Foster parents undergo extensive background checks and screening processes, revealing the bureaucratic nature of fostering. The emotional struggles of foster parents are discussed, focusing on the desire to protect children while grappling with the underlying issues that lead to child removal from their biological families. This duality of longing for adoption while the state mandates reunification processes adds layers of complexity to their caregiving experiences.
A Personal Touch in Paid Caregiving
The episode addresses the often-overlooked emotional connections formed between caregivers and those they assist, particularly among disabled individuals. Caregivers can become integral parts of their clients' lives, filling roles that extend beyond mere assistance, sometimes resembling friendships. The relationship dynamic is emphasized as caregivers and clients develop personal bonds, with caregivers having a significant influence on their clients' emotional well-being. This personal dimension of caregiving becomes evident through anecdotes that illustrate how caregivers share experiences and create meaningful moments together.
When Delores moved to New York City from Jamaica nearly thirty years ago she didn’t know anyone. But soon she found a community of other nannies and learned how to navigate job interviews and “fussy” parents who don’t like nannies to tell their children no.
In this week’s episode on paid caretaking, we explore the class and power dynamics inherent in care work. Plus, we hear from Faye*, a woman living with debilitating multiple sclerosis, and her husband Murray*, about how hiring outside help for caregiving shifts became essential to supporting their marriage.
Are you taking care of a loved one with MS? Murray suggests starting here for resources.
*Names have been changed.
Read Koa Beck’s essay about becoming a foster parent: “Nanny of the State.”
Death, Sex & Money is now produced by Slate! To support us and our colleagues, please sign up for our membership program, Slate Plus! Members get ad-free podcasts, bonus content on lots of Slate shows, and full access to all the articles on Slate.com. Sign up today at slate.com/dsmplus.
And if you’re new to the show, welcome. We’re so glad you’re here. Find us and follow us on Instagram and you can find Anna’s newsletter at annasale.substack.com. Our new email address, where you can reach us with voice memos, pep talks, questions, critiques, is deathsexmoney@slate.com.