The podcast discusses Germany's response to the Russian gas embargo after the invasion of Ukraine, highlighting the country's dependency on Russian gas and the economic effects. It explores the role of patriotism and solidarity, the macro output reduction due to lack of substitution possibilities, and compares the gas debate to the price cap on Russian oil. The chapter also emphasizes the importance of understanding market circumstances and the limitations of models in analyzing big shocks.
Germany successfully navigated the gas shock by finding alternative sources and reducing consumption, resulting in a minimal GDP drop in line with economists' predictions.
Understanding market circumstances and incorporating substitution are crucial in mitigating the macroeconomic effects of energy shocks, highlighting the need for better monitoring and planning strategies for future crises.
Deep dives
The Great German Gas Debate and its Implications
The podcast episode discusses the Great German Gas Debate and its implications on the German economy. It explores the predictions made by economists Benjamin Moll and Geric Zachman regarding the economic costs of cutting off gas imports from Russia. The episode highlights how the predictions were met with skepticism and sparked a heated debate in Germany. However, when the gas supply was cut off due to the Nord Stream 1 gas pipeline being blown up, Germany managed to find alternative sources of gas and significantly reduced gas consumption. As a result, the German economy only experienced a mini recession with a 0.5% drop in GDP, which was in line with the economists' predictions. The episode emphasizes the importance of substitution and the role it played in mitigating the economic impact of the gas shock. It also discusses the need for better monitoring of dependencies and improved planning strategies for similar situations in the future.
Lessons for Energy Market Shocks
This part of the podcast focuses on the broader implications of the German gas debate for other energy market shocks. It discusses the importance of understanding market circumstances and idiosyncratic factors that can influence the outcomes of such shocks. The episode highlights the power of substitution and the significance of having a low but non-zero elasticity of substitution in mitigating macroeconomic effects. It also addresses the geopolitical implications and lessons for other debates, such as the price cap on Russian oil. The economists emphasize the need for better enforcement and potentially lowering the price cap to further impact Putin's revenue sources. The episode concludes by discussing the importance of economists being willing to make forward-looking predictions and the challenges in doing so within the academic and research funding structures.
Reflections on the Role of Economists in Crises
This part of the podcast reflects on the role of economists in crises and the reluctance to make forward-looking predictions. The economists acknowledge that while predicting the outcomes of specific shocks can be challenging, it is important for economists to take intellectual risks and make predictions based on robust data and theoretical frameworks. They discuss the difficulties faced by colleagues in engaging in debates due to academic incentives and funding constraints. The episode highlights the importance of creating institutions and capacities specifically dedicated to crisis analysis and response. It also addresses the limitations of existing models in analyzing extreme shocks and calls for more flexibility in stretching model boundaries. The economists conclude by emphasizing the need for institutions to adapt and be prepared to tackle crisis situations effectively.
After the Russian invasion of Ukraine, there was a heated debate in Germany about whether to embargo the import of Russian natural gas as a sanction against Russia’s aggression. Before Germany could act, Russian began cutting the flow of gas to Germany, eventually halting it entirely. On this episode of the Brookings Podcast on Economic Activity, Benjamin Moll and Georg Zachmann talk with Economic Studies Director Ben Harris about how Germany navigated this tense situation, as well as their prior work that helped spur the "Great German Gas Debate."
The Brookings Podcast on Economic Activity is part of the Brookings Podcast Network. Subscribe and listen on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Send feedback email to podcasts@brookings.edu.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode