The Sunday Read: ‘This Is the Holocaust Story I Said I Wouldn’t Write’
May 4, 2025
auto_awesome
Taffy Brodesser-Akner, a writer for The New York Times Magazine, dives into the poignant story of Mr. Lindenblatt, a Holocaust survivor, as she grapples with her own connection to his narrative. She reflects on the weight of inherited trauma and the importance of sharing survivor stories for future generations. Taffy discusses the emotional complexities of combining childhood innocence with heavy historical themes, highlighting the urgency to preserve these legacies amid today's rising antisemitism. This intimate exploration underscores the power of storytelling in understanding and confronting the past.
The urgency to document Holocaust survivor narratives intensifies as the last bearers of these stories approach the end of their lives.
The speaker's reluctance to engage with her family's Holocaust history highlights the cultural disconnect many descendants experience with their legacy.
Confronting inherited trauma promotes a deeper understanding of identity, emphasizing the need for active engagement with cultural histories amidst modern challenges.
Deep dives
The Reluctance to Share Holocaust Stories
The speaker reflects on her long-standing reluctance to share Holocaust stories, despite being asked by Mr. Lindenblatt, a family friend and Holocaust survivor, to narrate his experience. She explains this hesitation stemmed from a saturation of Holocaust narratives throughout her upbringing and her desire to distance herself from that history as she sought to define her identity as an American Jew. However, upon learning of his terminal illness, she experiences a sense of urgency, realizing that the opportunity to tell such stories could soon be lost as the last survivors pass away. This revelation triggers a reflection on the importance of documenting and sharing these individual experiences, emphasizing that each survivor's narrative holds significant value beyond mere statistics of historical events.
Understanding Personal Connection to Trauma
The narrative delves into the speaker's own family history of Holocaust survival, prompting her to question the perception of her family as survivors. Initially unaware of her family's trauma, the speaker discusses her grandmother's vague responses regarding their past and her mother’s acknowledgment of their survivor status. This personal exploration intensifies her realization that denying this heritage only perpetuates a cultural disconnect. She concludes that regardless of individual identification with the trauma, it bonds generations and influences how descendants perceive and engage with their heritage.
The Burden of Inherited Trauma
Throughout the discussion, the speaker contemplates how the experiences of Holocaust survivors shape the identities of subsequent generations and manifest in different ways. The trauma does not simply dissipate; rather, it morphs and may remain unrecognized by those who bear its weight. The speaker acknowledges that her efforts to escape identification with this trauma were futile and ultimately led her back to it. By confronting this inherited burden, the speaker begins to appreciate that even avoidance is a form of engagement with their cultural history.
The Duty to Preserve Survivor Stories
The speaker grapples with the implications of living in a post-survivor era, where the number of individuals who experienced the Holocaust firsthand is dwindling. This raises the critical question of how to ensure that these narratives continue to resonate with future generations. She reflects on technological advancements in preserving these stories, such as interactive programs that replicate survivor experiences, emphasizing the need for innovation in Holocaust education. As the final testimonies of survivors become scarce, the urgency to document their stories intensifies, highlighting our responsibility to learn from and honor these legacies.
Reflections on Legacy and Action
The episode culminates in a profound contemplation of legacy, identity, and social responsibility amidst rising antisemitism. The speaker connects her family's history with contemporary challenges facing Jewish communities, pondering the implications of silent acceptance versus active remembrance and advocacy. She acknowledges her own fears and discomfort about confronting these issues publicly, ultimately recognizing that engaging with her heritage is not just about remembrance, but about actively challenging the narratives being created in the present. This reflection serves as a call to action, urging listeners to reflect on how they can uphold the legacy of survival and combat emerging prejudices in their own lives.
When Taffy Brodesser-Akner became a writer, Mr. Lindenblatt, the father of one of her oldest friends, began asking to tell his story of survival during the Holocaust in one of the magazines or newspapers she wrote for. He took pride in telling his story, in making sure he fulfilled what he felt was the obligation of all Holocaust survivors, which was to remind the world what had happened to the Jews.
His daughter Ilana knew it was a long shot but felt obligated to pass on the request — it was her father, after all. Taffy declined because after a life hearing about the Holocaust, she said, she was “all Holocausted out.”
But, years later, when she learned of Mr. Lindenblatt’s imminent passing, Taffy asked herself what would become of stories like his if the generation of hers that was supposed to inherit them had taken the privilege that came with another generation’s survival and decided not to listen?
So here it is, an old Jewish story about the Holocaust and a man who somehow survived the pernicious, organized and intentional genocide of the Jews. But right behind it, just two generations later, is another story, one about the children and grandchildren who have been so malformed by the stories that are their lineage that some of them made just as eager work of running from it, only to find themselves, same as anything you run from, having to deal with it anyway.
Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
