Marianne Eloise, a journalist and music writer, unpacks her struggle with having a Fall Out Boy song stuck in her head for over three years. She dives into the science behind earworms, discussing how certain melodies become irresistible. The conversation touches on the unique structure of pop-punk music and personal anecdotes about catchy tunes. Additionally, the exploration of songwriting techniques sheds light on why these songs linger. Marianne even discovers new insights from the Lemon Twigs about their own earworm challenges.
The podcast explores the cognitive science of earworms, detailing how specific melodies can become stuck in one's mind due to the phonological loop.
Creators of catchy music, like The Lemon Twigs, reveal that earworm hooks often arise organically rather than being intentionally crafted to ensnare listeners.
Deep dives
The Struggles with Earworms
Earworms, or catchy melodies that get stuck in one's head, are a prevalent yet frustrating experience for many. The podcast features a discussion about an individual named Marion, who has been haunted by a specific earworm, a song by Fall Out Boy, for over three years. Despite being a dedicated music writer and fan, Marion finds that this particular song, which she doesn't even love, continues to replay in her mind each morning. The emotional toll of such persistent earworms is highlighted, as they can interfere with daily life and even outcomes during significant moments, like her recent engagement while the song plagued her thoughts.
Understanding Musical Memory
The podcast delves into the cognitive science behind why certain songs become earworms, introducing concepts like the phonological loop. This loop refers to how the brain retains short snippets of auditory information, which can sometimes malfunction and cause unwanted repetition of melodies. The conversation reveals that earworms often consist of only small segments of a song, which can turn into an endless loop in one's mind. The explanation suggests that both neurologically predisposed individuals and music enthusiasts might be particularly susceptible to earworms, due to their extensive exposure and engagement with music.
Attempts to Eliminate Earworms
Various methods for getting rid of earworms are explored, ranging from chewing gum to listening to the song in full. Marion attempted these strategies without success, ultimately leading her to seek guidance from experts in music cognition. Despite her efforts to engage with the troublesome song or completely avoid it, the earworm persisted, demonstrating the challenging nature of these musical hooks. Recommendations from experts ranged from listening techniques to engaging actively with music through playing an instrument, but each individual experiences different outcomes.
Finding Solutions Through Engagement
The discussion then shifts towards a more personal approach by engaging directly with earworms through learning and playing music. The podcast hosts suggest that deeply understanding a song might help alleviate the mental grip it has on a person. By interviewing the Lemon Twigs, the creators of one of their earworms, it is discovered that the hooks in their music were not deliberately designed to ensnare listeners but emerged organically during the writing process. This realization points to a method of coping with earworms: embracing them through active engagement, such as playing or covering the song to dissipate its hold over the mind.
Marianne Eloise has had the same Fall Out Boy song stuck in her head for over three years. "It’s Hard to Say 'I Do,' When I Don’t," an relatively obscure cut from the band's 2007 album Infinity on High has taken up permanent residence in her brain as the ultimate earworm. Everybody has had a riff or a melody stuck in their head, but not at this . Eloise, a journalist and music writer, decided to turn her malady into a story. Her pursuit of the science behind "stuck songs" led her to our unique bureau of forensic musicology.
On this episode of Switched on Pop, Charlie and Nate talk about earworms: what they are, why are they so catchy, and how we might get rid of them. Then, Nate confronts his own stuck song: The Lemon Twigs's "In My Head," and in talking to the two brothers behind the group, finds a novel approach to giving an unwanted musical guest the boot.
Songs Discussed
Fall Out Boy - It’s Hard to Say “I Do,” When I Don’t