Increments
#64 - Libertarianism I: Intro and Moral Issues (w/ Bruce Nielson)
Episode guests
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- Libertarianism emphasizes individual autonomy and minimal government involvement in social and fiscal matters.
- Taxation is debated as either necessary contributions to societal well-being or viewed as theft and coercion.
- Implementing libertarian ideals on a large scale faces challenges due to the complexities of governance and societal interdependencies.
- A Libertarian utopia envisions private choice in public services and competition among service providers shaping community rules.
- Taxation in a Libertarian framework is reframed as contractual membership fees to lawmaking and law enforcement entities.
Deep dives
Introduction to Libertarianism and Series Overview
The podcast episode initiates a deep dive into libertarianism with the guest, Bruce Nielsen. It sets the stage for discussing various topics within libertarianism, focusing on moral issues rather than just economic concerns. The series is structured to cover economic, social, political, and moral issues related to libertarianism.
Libertarianism Ideology and Moral Arguments
The conversation delves into the distinction between conservative and libertarian ideologies, highlighting the moral arguments that underpin libertarian viewpoints. It explores the belief that government intrusion is immoral, framing taxation as theft and coercion. The discussion emphasizes the libertarian push for minimal government involvement in both social and fiscal aspects of life, rooted in individual autonomy and freedom.
Debate on Taxation and Government Involvement
A thought experiment known as 'Georgia O'Dowd, O'Dowd' is dissected, questioning the morality and coercion behind taxation. Different perspectives emerge on whether taxes are viewed as theft or necessary contributions to societal well-being. The conversation unravels the complexities of taxation, public goods, and individual responsibility within varying libertarian and non-libertarian frameworks.
Critique and Discussion on Libertarian Proposals
The critiques highlight the challenges of implementing libertarian solutions at a larger societal scale, emphasizing the unavoidable nature of governance and collective decision-making. The discourse contemplates the inherent dilemmas of taxation, societal interdependencies, and the practical realities of implementing privatized governance models. In navigating the nuances of libertarian proposals, complexities arise around defining theft, consent, and the role of governance in societal structures.
The Libertarian Utopia Proposal: Private Choice and Competition in Public Services
In the podcast episode, the concept of a Libertarian utopia is explored, advocating for private choice in public services like law enforcement and lawmaking. In this scenario, individuals can choose among various service providers for police forces, courts, and lawmaking bodies, allowing them to 'vote with their money'. The discussion delves into the potential benefits of competition among service providers in shaping a community's services and rules.
The Evolution Towards Common Morality in a Libertarian Environment
Within the Libertarian framework, the podcast outlines how multiple competing law-making and law-enforcing organizations might converge towards a common morality due to market pressures. Through contracts and market forces, these organizations are compelled to align on shared moral standards to retain trust and financial support from individuals. The discussion points out the development of common rules across companies and the role of consumer choice in influencing service provision.
Reimagining Government Services as Membership Fees
The episode presents an analogy whereby traditional taxes are reframed as membership fees paid to lawmaking and law enforcement entities. Emphasizing the contractual nature of these fees, the argument parallels them to homeowner association dues. This perspective challenges the notion of taxes as theft and underscores the contractual basis of financial contributions for essential public services.
Addressing Public Goods Provision in a Libertarian Society
The conversation expands to discuss public goods provision within libertarian ideology, highlighting challenges in funding public goods like parks, clean air, and emergency services through voluntary donations. The debate touches on funding mechanisms such as dominant assurance contracts and explores the potential for privatizing traditionally government-provided services like police forces, fire departments, and postal services.
Navigating the Intersection of Moral Argument and Pragmatism
Throughout the episode, the interplay between moral arguments and pragmatic considerations in political discourse is examined. The complexity arises in translating moral convictions into practical policies and addressing diverse perspectives on issues like taxation, abortion, and public goods provision. The importance of grounding moral theories in testable consequences and balancing normative claims with pragmatic realities is underscored as crucial in constructive political dialogue and decision-making.
Liberty! Freedom! Coercion! Taxes are theft! The State is The Enemy! Bitcoin! Crypto! Down with the central banks! Let's all return to the Gold Standard!
Have you encountered such phrases in the wild? Confused, perhaps, as to why an afternoon beer with a friend become an extended diatribe against John Maynard Kaynes? Us too, which is why we're diving into the ideological source of such views: Libertarianism.
Welcome to Part 1 of a four part series where we, with Bruce Nielson (@bnielson01) as our battle-hardened guide, dive into Scott Alexander's non-libertarian FAQ. Ought George help, or ought George respect the government's property rights? Let's find out.
And make sure to check out Bruce's excellent The Theory Of Anything podcast here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-theory-of-anything/id1503194218
We discuss
- Varieties of libertarianism
- Why are some libertarians so ideological?
- Is taxation theft?
- The problem of public goods
- "Proprietary communities" and the perfect libertarian society
- Why the perfect libertarian society doesn't escape taxation
- Are we living in the libertarian utopia right now?
- Taxes as membership fees
References
- The Non-libertarian FAQ
- George ought to help
- The Machinery of Freedom by David Friedman
Vaden's blog posts on Libertarianism / Austrian Economics / Anarcho-Captialism / Whateveryawannacallit
- First: Is Austrian Economics the Best Explanation of Economics?
- Second: Can we predict human behaviour? A discussion with Brett Hall
Quotes
0.2: Do you hate libertarianism?
No.To many people, libertarianism is a reaction against an over-regulated society, and an attempt to spread the word that some seemingly intractable problems can be solved by a hands-off approach. Many libertarians have made excellent arguments for why certain libertarian policies are the best options, and I agree with many of them. I think this kind of libertarianism is a valuable strain of political thought that deserves more attention, and I have no quarrel whatsoever with it and find myself leaning more and more in that direction myself.
However, there’s a certain more aggressive, very American strain of libertarianism with which I do have a quarrel. This is the strain which, rather than analyzing specific policies and often deciding a more laissez-faire approach is best, starts with the tenet that government can do no right and private industry can do no wrong and uses this faith in place of more careful analysis. This faction is not averse to discussing politics, but tends to trot out the same few arguments about why less regulation has to be better. I wish I could blame this all on Ayn Rand, but a lot of it seems to come from people who have never heard of her. I suppose I could just add it to the bottom of the list of things I blame Reagan for.
- https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/22/repost-the-non-libertarian-faq/
Socials
- Follow us on Twitter at @IncrementsPod, @BennyChugg, @VadenMasrani
- Come join our discord server! DM us on twitter or send us an email to get a supersecret link
- Help us curtail freedom and get exclusive bonus content by becoming a patreon subscriber here. Or give us one-time cash donations to help cover our lack of cash donations here.
- Click dem like buttons on youtube
How do you summon libertarians at a party? Finish the punchline and tell us over at incrementspodcast@gmail.com
Special Guest: Bruce Nielson.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
