S8 E6: Bank Nerd Corner: What is the BSCA and What Can It Do?
Aug 14, 2024
auto_awesome
In this episode, Jim Bergin, a seasoned partner at Arnold & Porter with nearly two decades at the Federal Reserve, dives into the intriguing world of banking regulations. He clarifies the origins and evolution of the Bank Service Company Act (BSCA) since the 1960s. The trio also tackles recent Supreme Court decisions and their potential ramifications for banks and fintechs. Kiah shares her thoughts on brokered deposits, questioning why the FDIC is still focused on classifying fintech deposits rather than adapting to modern financial behaviors.
The Bank Service Company Act was established in the 1960s to enhance technological collaboration among banks and has evolved over time.
Recent Supreme Court decisions significantly impact regulatory frameworks for financial services, especially concerning statutory limitations and federal preemption.
The debate over brokered deposits and their classification highlights the need for updated regulations that align with contemporary banking practices and risks.
Deep dives
Impact of Supreme Court Rulings on Financial Services
Recent Supreme Court decisions hold significant implications for the financial services industry, particularly regarding statutory limitations and federal preemption. The Corner Post case clarifies how long a party has to bring a claim of injury, potentially extending the statute of limitations from the time of formation. Similarly, the Cantaro case addresses federal preemption, examining whether an OCC-regulated bank must adhere to state laws under a national charter. These rulings not only reshape the regulatory landscape for banks but also influence how non-bank financial service providers operate under government oversight.
Insights from an Experienced Federal Reserve Professional
Jim Bergen, a partner at Arnold and Porter, shares his extensive experience with the Federal Reserve, highlighting his tenure during the 2008 financial crisis. Having worked in various roles, he gained crucial insights into banking regulations, particularly regarding capital requirements and funding challenges faced by holding companies. This period shaped his understanding of central banking while exposing him to the complexities of financial market dynamics. His unique perspective is invaluable in grasping the current state of bank regulation and its implications for both traditional and fintech entities.
Understanding the Bank Service Company Act
The Bank Service Company Act (BSCA) is a key piece of legislation that allows bank regulators to supervise entities providing services to banks. Originating in the 1960s to enable banks to collaborate on technological advancements, the Act has evolved to address contemporary banking needs. Its broad language encompasses various service arrangements, yet questions remain about its applicability to modern fintech partnerships. As banks increasingly rely on third-party providers, understanding the Act's provisions and the regulatory authority it grants has become essential in navigating the evolving landscape of banking services.
Fintech Partnerships and Regulatory Scrutiny
The dialogue surrounding fintech partnerships and the BSCA highlights the importance of clarity and accountability in financial services. With rising concerns over consumer protection and the integrity of banking systems, regulators are scrutinizing the relationships between banks and their service providers more closely. This scrutiny comes amidst debates about the evolving nature of deposits and the risks they carry for banks' safety and soundness. As banks and fintechs navigate these regulatory challenges, the definition and classification of services under the BSCA will play a pivotal role in shaping future compliance and operational strategies.
The Debate Over Broker Deposits and Regulatory Changes
The FDIC's recent interest in reversing the 2020 update to the broker deposit definition has sparked significant debate in the financial sector. Historically, brokered deposits have been viewed as high-risk, rate-seeking funds, leading to concerns about their impact on bank stability. Critics argue that applying the broker designation to current fintech deposits ignores the evolving nature of these funds, which often facilitate transactions rather than serving as traditional savings. This discussion highlights the need for updated regulations that reflect modern deposit behaviors and the intricate relationships formed in the fintech landscape.
This week on Bank Nerd Corner, special guest and partner at Arnold & Porter, Jim Bergin joins the pod. Having worked for the Federal Reserve for 18 years, Kiah and Alex pry into his legal expertise to get answers to some lingering questions.
Jim explains the history and purpose of the Bank Service Company Act, a law enacted in the 1960s in response to the burgeoning technology needs of banks. He explains what the BSCA was originally designed for, and how it has evolved over the decades.
Alex, Kiah, and Jim also discuss the recent Supreme Court decision that ended the Chevron deference, as well as a pile of other recent Supreme Court decisions that have the potential to impact banks and fintech companies.
Plus, our girl Kiah has some major thoughts when it comes to brokered deposits. We all know that deposits behave differently— so why, in this day and age, is the FDIC still acting like the most important thing it can do is reclassify fintech deposits from non-brokered to brokered?
Sign up for Alex’s Fintech Takes newsletter for the latest insightful analysis on fintech trends, along with a heaping pile of pop culture references and copious footnotes. Every Monday and Thursday: https://workweek.com/brand/fintech-takes/
And for more exclusive insider content, don’t forget to check out my YouTube page.
