Ussama Makdisi, expert on Western colonialism and Zionism, discusses how these forces exploited and imposed sectarianism in the Arab Middle East. Topics include the impact of Western imperialism, the divergence between Turkey and Arab Mushryk, Arab political radicalisms, the emergence of the Arab identity, early Palestinian opposition to Zionism, consequences of colonialism and Zionism, the Farhud and colonial Zionist project, and demystifying violent events in the Middle East.
The imposition of colonial Zionism in Palestine led to the fragmentation of religious communities and eroded the ecumenical identity that had previously encompassed Muslims, Christians, and Jews.
The violence and clashes between Arabs and Jews in Palestine were framed by Zionist and British colonial officials to depict Palestinians as barbaric, reinforcing harmful stereotypes and obscuring the historical context.
The exclusive and sectarian nature of colonial Zionism shattered the unity and coexistence among different religious communities in Palestine, perpetuating divisions between Arab and Jew.
The impact of colonial Zionism on coexistence in Palestine has created ongoing challenges for Palestinians in their struggle for justice and self-determination amidst the dominance of a colonial Zionist political project in the region.
Deep dives
The Impact of Colonial Zionism on the Ecumenical Frame in Palestine
The podcast episode explores the impact of colonial Zionism on the ecumenical frame in Palestine. Colonial Zionism, backed by British colonial authorities, imposed a sectarian and exclusivist ideology that shattered the unity and coexistence among different religious communities in Palestine. The episode highlights the historical context and the ideological conflicts that emerged during the early 20th century between Zionists, Arab nationalists, and the British mandate. It emphasizes the role of colonial Zionism in creating a binary opposition between Arab and Jew, eroding the ecumenical identity that had previously encompassed Muslims, Christians, and Jews. The episode also discusses the violent clashes that occurred between Arabs and Jews, examining the framing and misrepresentation of these conflicts by Zionists and British colonial officials. Moreover, the episode addresses the critiques and proposals put forth by Arab leaders like George Antonius, who advocated for a fair and inclusive solution to the Arab-Jewish question in Palestine. It highlights the dismissive response of the British to these proposals, and the detrimental consequences of disregarding Palestinian demands for a secular democratic state.
The Role of Hajj Amin al-Husseini and Palestinian Response to Colonial Zionism
The podcast episode also touches upon the role of Palestinian leader Hajj Amin al-Husseini and the response of the Palestinian population to colonial Zionism. It acknowledges that while Hajj Amin later collaborated with the Nazis, it was a reaction to the oppressive and coercive nature of colonial Zionism and the suffering experienced by the Palestinians. The episode clarifies the fallacy of portraying Palestinians as fundamentally anti-Semitic and responsible for the Holocaust, arguing that such claims divert attention from the historical context of British colonialism and Zionist settler colonialism. It underscores the significance of understanding the chronology of events and the conditions under which Hajj Amin and other Palestinian leaders made their choices. Overall, the episode emphasizes the need to contextualize the actions and decisions of individuals within the broader historical dynamics and power imbalances created by colonial intervention.
Violence, Framing, and the Discourses of British Colonialism and Orientalism
The podcast episode delves into the framing of violence perpetrated by Zionist settlers and responses by the British colonial authorities. It examines how British imperialists and Zionist settlers shaped the narrative around the violence, portraying it as mob-driven pogroms and sectarian conflicts, thereby obscuring their own complicity in the violence. The episode highlights the inherent bias in framing the resistance of Palestinians as barbaric, while portraying British rule as the civilized order. It reveals the Orientalist discourses that informed these framings, perpetuating stereotypes about Arab and Muslim violence. The episode elucidates the long-lasting implications of these discourses, which have influenced contemporary narratives regarding Arab and Muslim violence, reinforcing harmful stereotypes and obscuring the underlying historical and political context.
The Undermining of Coexistence and the Legacy of Colonial Zionism
Lastly, the podcast episode addresses the profound impact of colonial Zionism on the ecumenical frame and coexistence in Palestine. It underscores how the exclusivist nature of colonial Zionism shattered the unity and harmony among different religious communities, eroding the possibility of an inclusive and democratic state where citizens are equal regardless of their religious background. The episode emphasizes the legacy of colonial Zionism in perpetuating the differentiation and divisions between Arab and Jew. It highlights the ongoing challenges faced by Palestinians in their struggle for justice, self-determination, and coexistence amidst the continued dominance of a colonial Zionist political project in the region.
The significance of coexistence and colonial Zionism in the Arab world
The podcast episode explores the historical significance of coexistence and colonial Zionism in the Arab world. It emphasizes how the brutal suppression of the anti-colonial revolt in Palestine in 1936 galvanized anti-Zionist sentiment across the Arab world and stigmatized Arab Jews as potential agents of Zionism. A key moment is the 1941 Farhud attacks in Baghdad, which killed 180 Jews and revealed the transformation of the region's capacity for coexistence due to Zionism and larger colonial forces. The episode highlights the tragic consequences of the breakdown of coexistence and the missed opportunity to build new alliances after the Farhud, as colonial Zionism turned it into part of its project.
The consequences of mass displacement of Mizrahi Jews
The podcast delves into the mass displacement of Mizrahi Jews from Arab countries, specifically focusing on the experiences of Iraqi Jews in Baghdad. It explores how Zionist agents and the Iraqi government played significant roles in creating the conditions for the exodus. The episode emphasizes the catastrophic human and social failure resulting from the expulsion, stressing that Arab and Jewish identities should not be conflated. It highlights the potential for Arab-Jewish coexistence and warns against the conflation of religious and political identities, emphasizing that such conflation was a consequence of colonial Zionism and should have been a warning to advocate for collaboration and new forms of coexistence.
The legacy of the Nakba and the future of Arab politics
The podcast discusses the legacy of the Nakba, the defeat in Palestine in 1948, and its impact on Arab politics. It notes how the defeat led to a renewed commitment among Arabs to an ecumenical nationalist frame, aiming for systemic reform and sovereignty to counter Western colonialism and Zionism. The episode highlights the diversity of responses, from secular nationalist to more Islamist and communist perspectives. It emphasizes the ongoing struggle for justice, the dire consequences of sectarian violence and foreign intervention in the region, and the potential for a future marked by reconstituted Arab-Jewish or Muslim-Christian-Jewish coexistence. Lastly, it acknowledges the importance of the current mobilization for Palestinian rights, which creates an ecumenical frame for left politics and fosters a new internationalism within the American left.
Featuring Ussama Makdisi on how Western colonialism and Zionism exploited, exacerbated, and imposed sectarianism across the Arab Middle East. This is the SECOND of a two-part interview.
Support The Dig at Patreon.com/TheDig
Contact Spotify and tell them: stop hiding The Dig! Why is The Dig so hard to find on Spotify? support.spotify.com/contact-spotify-support/
Check out our newsletter and vast archives at thedigradio.com
Buy The Good Die Young: The Verdict on Henry Kissinger at versobooks.com
Buy War Made Invisible thenewpress.com/books/war-made-invisible
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode