Col Doug Macgregor: Trump Putin Phone Call FALLOUT /Europe in a PANIC!

18 snips

May 20, 2025

Doug Macgregor, a defense and foreign policy analyst and former advisor to the Secretary of Defense, dives into the fallout from Trump's recent call with Putin. He critiques Trump's approach, suggesting it mischaracterizes U.S. neutrality while fueling Russian stalling tactics. The conversation spotlights Russia's steadfast demands for Ukrainian neutrality and the misconceptions held by Western leaders about the conflict's dynamics. Macgregor underscores Europe's growing panic over the situation, illustrating a critical disconnect between aspirations for quick resolution and the reality of prolonged conflict.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

US Not Neutral Mediator

Trump doesn't realize the US is a party in the Ukraine conflict, not a neutral mediator.
His walking away if talks fail actually gives Russia incentive to stall negotiations.

INSIGHT

Europe's Unrealistic Ukraine Goals

Europe wants influence over postwar Ukraine and its military alignment, which Russia will never allow.
Russia's patience is strong as Europe is financially and politically unstable.

INSIGHT

Russia Uses Talks To Stall

Russian public opposes concessions after heavy war losses.
Kremlin signals there are no deadlines; peace talks are a stalling tactic while continuing the war.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

Trump's Perspective:

Trump claimed he urged Putin to end the "bloodbath" in Ukraine.
He suggested he told Putin if an agreement couldn’t be reached, he’d walk away from negotiations.
He framed the conversation as positive and believed Putin wants peace.

Criticism of Trump’s Approach:

Analysts argue Trump showed naïveté and misunderstood the dynamics.
By saying he'd walk away if talks fail, he may have incentivized Russia to stall.
Trump also ignores the fact that the U.S. is not a neutral mediator—it is a co-belligerent supporting Ukraine.

Russia’s Consistent Position:

Putin has not changed his demands: Ukrainian neutrality, Russian control of annexed territories, recognition of Crimea, and "denazification".
Russian media and officials saw the call as a win, giving them more time while projecting openness to peace.
The "memorandum" mentioned is seen as a vague tool to stall and delay real negotiations.

Russian Strategy and Sentiment:

Russia is in no rush to end the war without securing strategic goals.
Domestic Russian sentiment opposes making concessions after heavy casualties.
Officials like Peskov are signaling patience, with no deadlines, implying that talks are more for show.

U.S. and European Misunderstandings:

Western leaders are accused of misjudging Russia’s intentions and resilience.
Europe wants influence in postwar Ukraine, which Russia will not allow.
Putin is seen as willing to drag the conflict out to secure a permanent outcome, unlike the West’s desire for a quick resolution.

Media Commentary:

Russian media praised Putin’s performance and diplomatic skill.
U.S. analysts like Jack Keane and J.D. Vance made misinformed or inconsistent statements, showing a poor grasp of Russia's strategy and public sentiment.

Conclusion:

Russia remains unmoved and strategically consistent.
Trump’s impatience and misunderstanding of the geopolitical landscape could undermine his credibility.
Any peace talks that don’t acknowledge Russia’s fundamental conditions are likely to be fruitless or drawn out indefinitely.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.