Unholy: Two Jews on the News Emergency update - Strike on Hamas in Qatar
7 snips
Sep 9, 2025 Amos Harel, a military affairs analyst for Haaretz, joins the discussion to unpack Israel's unprecedented military action against Hamas in Qatar. The conversation dives into the complex motivations behind the strikes, whether tactical responses or strategic disruptions in negotiations. Harel explores regional implications and the shifting power dynamics in the Middle East. The dialogue also touches on the intricate challenges of hostage negotiations and the potential effects on Israel's political landscape.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Political Motive Behind The Strike
- Amos Harel argues Netanyahu acted because he can and to avoid a hostage deal under current circumstances.
- The strike serves domestic political aims and signals continuation of the war rather than enabling negotiations.
Eliminating Exiles Won't Shift Gaza's Leaders
- Harel doubts removing external Hamas figures will change Gaza leadership decisions led by hardliners inside Gaza.
- He sees the strike as a statement that Israel can reach targets in Qatar, not as a negotiation facilitator.
Unclear US Coordination
- Harel says US coordination around the strike is unclear and Trump may have been in the loop but not fully coordinated.
- He notes Netanyahu and Trump have largely aligned views on Hamas throughout the war.