The Fascist Foundations of Heideggerian Thought: A Marxist Critique with Colin Bodayle
May 12, 2025
auto_awesome
In a thought-provoking discussion, Colin Bodayle, a doctoral student at Villanova University specializing in Marx and Heidegger, reveals the disturbing links between Martin Heidegger's philosophy and fascism. He critiques how Heidegger’s concepts of authenticity and Dasein fundamentally support a fascist worldview. The conversation dives into the selective editing of Heidegger's manuscripts, the mystification around his Nazi past, and explores connections between German thinkers and far-right ideologies. Bodayle emphasizes the importance of confronting these uncomfortable truths in academia.
Colin Bodayle critiques Martin Heidegger's philosophical project as fundamentally intertwined with fascism, challenging the sanitized academic perspectives surrounding his Nazism.
The podcast emphasizes the necessity of reading Heidegger critically, acknowledging both his intellectual contributions and the troubling political implications of his thought.
A discussion on existential philosophy reveals the tension between individual identity and collective social movements in the context of Heidegger's ideas.
Colin analyzes the repurposing of Heideggerian concepts by contemporary far-right figures, highlighting the dangers of using tradition to exclude broader humanist values.
Deep dives
The Influence of German Idealism
The discussion centers on the enduring impact of German idealism, particularly focusing on figures like Hegel and Heidegger. They explore how these philosophers influence contemporary thought, especially within the context of leftist critiques. Colin highlights the dialectical approach prevalent in their writings, particularly how it differs from more materialist perspectives. The conversation reveals a tension between embracing these philosophers’ contributions while simultaneously critiquing their ideological underpinnings.
Heidegger's Controversial Legacy
Heidegger's affiliation with the Nazi Party and his philosophical ideas regarding being and existence are critically examined. There is a consensus on the necessity of reading Heidegger's work while being mindful of the political implications tied to his philosophies. The challenges arise in reconciling his brilliant insights with his troubling political affiliations, which leads to discussions on how this dichotomy influences modern receptions of his thought. The speakers emphasize a need for critical engagement rather than unquestioned acceptance of his ideas.
The Role of Language in Philosophy
The conversation emphasizes the complexity of language in philosophical discourse, particularly how philosophers often redefine terms, leading to misunderstandings. Colin mentions the struggle to reconcile concepts such as 'alterity' and 'metaphysics,' which are contested terms in contemporary philosophy. This highlights the importance of precision in language and the potential pitfalls of vague terminology. They argue for the need to unpack these concepts thoughtfully to avoid conflating differing philosophical arguments.
The Relationship between Technology and Being
Heidegger's view of technology as a manifestation of the will to power is analyzed, revealing his concerns over how modern technology shapes our understanding of being. The discussion highlights that while technology can enhance liberatory potential, it also poses risks of objectification. Colin critiques the idea that technology itself is inherently negative, instead emphasizing that the underlying economic and ideological systems dictate its implications. This reorientation suggests that a materialist critique might offer more productive insights into our relationship with technological advancements.
Interrogating Existentialism
The speakers delve into existential philosophy, focusing on the ways identity and subjectivity are constructed in Heidegger's work. They point out that existentialism often prioritizes individual experience, leading to challenges when addressing collective identities or social movements. This leads to discussions on how existentialism intersects with political ideologies, illustrating both its potential for liberation and its limitations. The conversation suggests that understanding existential concepts requires grappling with their broader socio-political implications.
Critiquing the Frankfurt School
Colin provides a critical look at the Frankfurt School's philosophical contributions, specifically examining the intersection of critical theory and critiques of culture. While acknowledging their influence, the conversation raises questions about their interpretations of ontology and how they relate to traditional Marxism. The speakers emphasize the need to critically engage with figures like Marcuse, noting the complexities of applying Frankfurt School ideas in contemporary contexts. This critique reflects the broader challenge of reconciling cultural critiques with materialist frameworks.
Revisiting the Notion of Tradition
The discussion takes a closer look at how concepts of tradition have been used by philosophical movements, particularly in fascist ideologies. They explore the ways in which thinkers like Dugan repurpose Heideggerian ideas for contemporary far-right discourses, critiquing the notion of preserving cultural identity at the expense of broader humanist values. The conversation underscores the tension present in discussions of tradition, examining how traditions can be both resources for resilience and tools of exclusion. This raises essential questions about how to navigate tradition in the context of modern political struggles.
What if I told you one of the most influential philosophers of the 20th century wasn't just a Nazi sympathizer, but that fascism was fundamental to his entire philosophical project? In this profound conversation with Colin Bodayle, doctoral student in philosophy at Villanova University, we peel back the sanitized layers of Martin Heidegger's legacy to reveal the uncomfortable truth behind his continued influence.
The mystification around Heidegger's Nazism represents one of academia's most persistent blind spots. While other Nazi intellectuals like Carl Schmitt are acknowledged for what they were, Heidegger enjoys special treatment. Colin reveals how Heidegger's manuscripts were likely edited to remove explicitly fascist content, creating a historical deception that continues to this day.
Most importantly, we explore how Heidegger's core philosophical concepts—authenticity, Dasein, and his critique of technology—directly support his fascist worldview. His concept of authenticity isn't about individual self-creation but about embracing one's heritage and historical destiny as part of a "folk." His subjective idealism dissolves the possibility of objective truth in favor of interpretation, creating a philosophical framework perfectly aligned with fascist thought.
The conversation takes fascinating detours through German idealism, Nietzsche's reactionary politics, and the strange appropriation of Heideggerian concepts by both the contemporary left and far-right figures like Alexander Dugin. We also discuss how continental philosophy's language games often obscure the political implications embedded in philosophical concepts.
Rather than suggesting we abandon these thinkers entirely, this conversation invites critical engagement. As Colin notes, "Heidegger can teach you things about being human—he wasn't wrong about everything." But we must approach his work with our eyes wide open to its political foundations.
If you've ever grappled with continental philosophy, critical theory, or the political dimensions of abstract thought, this episode offers a masterclass in intellectual clarity and honest critique.
Links and Social Media: twitter: @varnvlog blue sky: @varnvlog.bsky.social You can find the additional streams on Youtube
Current Patreon at the Sponsor Tier: Jordan Sheldon, Mark J. Matthews, Lindsay Kimbrough, RedWolf, DRV, Kenneth McKee, JY Chan, Matthew Monahan, Parzival, Adriel Mixon
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
