3 and Out with John Middlekauff Tomlin or McCarthy for the Giants? AJ Brown Speaks Out, Browns Drama & Purdy’s Future
Nov 13, 2025
In this episode, attorney Dan Morgan shares insights on legal practices while John dives into the debate over whether Mike Tomlin or Mike McCarthy would be a better fit for the Giants. They also discuss AJ Brown's candid comments on the Eagles, the challenges faced by the Browns, and the future of Brock Purdy with the 49ers. John addresses various fan questions, tackling topics like NFL replay rules, rookie QB development, and the competitive landscape of the NFC North.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Why McCarthy Makes Sense For The Giants
- Mike McCarthy fits the Giants because he handles bright lights and develops quarterbacks.
- John argues McCarthy's offense and playoff experience suit New York's need for stability.
Giants Need Proven Head-Coach Stability
- The Giants need an experienced head coach to stop cycling coordinators and reach the playoffs.
- John believes a proven head coach brings stability the franchise desperately lacks.
Get Numb To Pressure As You Rise
- Learn to manage stress as you gain responsibility; it determines coaching success.
- John stresses that head coaches must become numb to outside pressure quickly to survive.
