The Michael Shermer Show

Shermer Says: Why Secularists Are Turning to Religion, The Substitution Hypothesis, Sleep Paralysis

8 snips
Oct 18, 2025
Is society experiencing a cultural shift back to religion? Explore the historical Great Awakenings and the debate on whether secularism can substitute for faith. Michael Shermer delves into the implications of new literature on belief, group identity, and near-death experiences. He examines arguments for and against the resurgence of religiosity, including the neuroscience of the soul and how personal narratives shape divine perceptions. Lastly, Shermer shares his own stance as a religious skeptic in this thought-provoking discussion.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

The Fifth Great Awakening Question

  • Michael Shermer outlines four historical American Great Awakenings and suggests we may be entering a fifth wave of religiosity.
  • He links past awakenings to social movements like abolition, temperance, and the social gospel shaping civic institutions.
ANECDOTE

Shermer's Religious Backstory

  • Michael Shermer recounts his personal involvement in the late-60s/70s Jesus movement and becoming born-again in high school.
  • He describes attending The Barn, Pepperdine, and door-to-door evangelism before later becoming a skeptic.
INSIGHT

Substitution Hypothesis Examined

  • Shermer recounts a Free Press debate on whether the West needs a religious revival and cites rising polls showing a recent uptick in Christian identification.
  • He frames the substitution hypothesis that secular ideologies may fill religion's social role, and expresses skepticism about that claim.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app