Stuart Hameroff: Is the Human Brain a Quantum Computer? (#353)
Oct 2, 2023
auto_awesome
Dr. Stuart Hameroff discusses the Orch OR theory of consciousness and explores the role of quantum mechanics in understanding the human brain. Topics include anesthesia, artificial intelligence, and the potential for quantum properties in aromatic ring structures.
Consciousness may have fundamental significance and provide spiritual and philosophical insights if found to be an intrinsic feature of the universe.
Microtubules and coherent vibrations play a crucial role in consciousness, allowing for conscious awareness and free will.
Artificial intelligence is unlikely to achieve true consciousness due to the absence of microtubules, coherent vibrations, and mechanisms like Orch OR.
Deep dives
The importance of understanding consciousness
Understanding consciousness is significant for various reasons. If consciousness is found to be an intrinsic feature of the universe, it would reshape our perspective and provide spiritual and philosophical insights. It would connect us to the fundamental nature of reality on multiple levels. On the other hand, if consciousness is considered an emergent, epiphenomenal process, its significance may be diminished.
The role of microtubules and coherent vibrations in consciousness
Microtubules and coherent vibrations, such as megahertz and gigahertz frequencies, play a crucial role in the Orch OR theory of consciousness. Microtubules, present in neurons, exhibit complex interactions and information processing capabilities. The variations in firing thresholds on a beat-to-beat basis suggest the influence of something beyond traditional computation. Coherent vibrations in the megahertz and gigahertz range, detected from the scalp, show promise as potential neural correlates of consciousness. These elements, when combined, override automatic behavior and allow for conscious awareness and free will.
The limitations of AI in achieving consciousness
Artificial intelligence (AI) is unlikely to achieve consciousness, even though it may attempt to mimic it. The computational nature of AI, despite its increasing complexity, is not sufficient for true consciousness. The absence of microtubules and coherent vibrations, as well as the absence of mechanisms like Orch OR, prevents AI from exhibiting qualities like free will, creativity, and imagination associated with consciousness. AI may still have practical uses but is unlikely to possess genuine consciousness.
Quantum effects in the brain
The podcast episode discusses the possibility of quantum effects in the brain and how they might contribute to consciousness. While the idea of quantum consciousness is met with skepticism by many, the speaker argues that quantum phenomena, specifically entanglement, could potentially explain the unified consciousness experienced by humans. They explain that the small-scale gravitational effects involved in entanglement could evade decoherence timescales and persist long enough for conscious perception.
Microtubules and memory
The episode focuses on microtubules, which are protein structures found in all cells, particularly in the brain. The speaker highlights the unique qualities of microtubules in the brain, such as genetic variability and post-translational modifications, which make them suitable for memory storage. They propose that microtubules, rather than synapses, are responsible for memory storage and retrieval, as synapses have shorter lifetimes. Furthermore, the dendritic microtubules, which are stable over a lifetime, are suggested to play a crucial role in memory consolidation and long-term storage. The mixed polarity network formed by microtubules in dendrites and soma is believed to enable recursive processing and interference beats, potentially explaining phenomena like EEG activity.
Is the human brain a quantum computer? What is the Orch OR model of consciousness? And is there an afterlife for our quantum souls?
Here today to answer these questions and take us on a wild tour through consciousness, imagination, and the human brain is Dr. Stuart Hameroff! Stuart is a professor of anesthesiology and psychology at the University of Arizona and director of The Center for Consciousness Studies.
In this interview, we dive deep into Stuart’s research and his passion for everything consciousness, so make sure to check it out!
Key Takeaways:
Intro (00:00)
Judging the symposium by its cover (02:06)
The Orch OR theory (06:44)
The problem of free will (10:14)
Elaborating on the Orch OR theory (13:00)
How does anesthesia actually work? (26:23)
Stuart’s interest in quantum physics (30:10)
Artificial intelligence and brain organoids (33:55)
AI, Neuralink, and other brain-computer interfaces (38:02)
Audience questions (42:54)
Outro (55:53)
—
Additional resources:
🥗 Thanks, HelloFresh! Go to HelloFresh.com/50impossible and use code 50impossible for 50% off plus 15% off the next 2 months.
📝 With a MasterClass annual membership, you can take one-on-one classes from the world’s best for $10 a month with your annual membership, get unlimited access to every class — and even better, right now, as an Into The Impossible listener, you can get 15% off when you go to MASTERCLASS.com/impossible.