The hosts discuss the Israel-Hamas conflict, the issue of hostages, and the implications of the administration's decision on sanctioning West Bank settlers. They also talk about the Biden administration's actions in Gaza, perspectives on Israeli settlements, controversial politician statements, and a tragic massacre in France.
Both Israel and Hamas are torn over demands and potential hostage deals, with pressure on the Israeli government to make a decision.
The perception of Israeli settlers differs between those in Israel and outside, with settlements seen as a security measure but also viewed negatively internationally.
Unity among Israelis and support from Jews worldwide following the conflict are now facing strains, with divisions arising due to debates over the Israeli government's response.
Deep dives
The Struggle to Reach a Deal with Hamas
Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu believes total victory is within reach, while Hamas has rejected a potential hostage deal. The two sides remain torn over demands such as the release of Palestinian prisoners and a complete halt to the war. The longer the conflict persists, the greater the danger for the hostages still held by Hamas. There is pressure on the Israeli government to make a decision, with some advocating for a deal and others urging continued military pressure on Hamas. The current government is facing internal disagreements and political challenges, which are adding to the complexity of the situation.
Israeli Settlers and the Perception Divide
The perception of Israeli settlers differs greatly between those living in Israel and those outside of the country. Internationally, settlements are often viewed negatively due to their presence on disputed territory. However, within Israel, settlements are seen as a strategic and security measure. Some argue that settlements prevent attacks like the October 7th massacre, while others believe they hinder Israel's ability to define its borders. The issue of settlements is likely to remain contentious, with ongoing debates regarding their impact on Israeli security and prospects for peace.
Unity and Division in Israeli Society
Following the October 7th attack and the ensuing conflict, there was a sense of unity among Israelis, as well as a noticeable increase in support from Jews around the world. However, this unity is now facing strain, both within Israel and in the diaspora. Ongoing debates about the Israeli government's response to the conflict have led to divisions among Israelis, with differing opinions on when and how to proceed. In the diaspora, especially among younger generations, support for Israel is becoming more nuanced, with some finding it difficult to align with certain actions of the government. The challenge lies in maintaining connections and dialogue across these divisions in a post-war context.
The Return of Hamas in Gaza
There is evidence that Hamas is reemerging and reasserting control in Gaza, taking over administrative roles and conducting arrests. This poses a significant problem for Israel and raises questions about the purpose of the recent conflict. Some experts suggest the need for international administration to ensure civil order, although it would require a promise of a Palestinian state from Israel.
Accountability and Future Leadership in Israel
There are discussions about accountability and future leadership in Israel following the October 7th tragedy and the overall handling of the war. While Israel has a history of not taking responsibility for failures, the public anger may lead to a push for change. Questions arise about the next generation of military and political leaders. Some are looking to the civilian population, including heroic individuals during the conflict, as potential candidates for future leadership roles.
As talks aimed at a release of hostages and a pause in fighting grind on, Yonit and Jonathan look at what both Israel and Hamas stand to gain - and lose - from any deal. And they take a fresh round of listener questions that have come in from all over the world - on Gaza the day after, new leadership in Israel and how Jews and Israelis who disagree can keep talking. Plus: Australian chutzpah and a French mensch.
--
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/unholypodcast/ Join our Facebook group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1150578065793142
Join Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland for a special night of news and surprises—live on stage, June 8th 2025. If you’ve ever wanted to see the podcast come to life, now’s your chance. Reserve your seat now via the link—space is limited, and we’d love to see you there! https://bit.ly/UnholyLondonLive
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
