Make Me Smart

The myth America exported to the world

Nov 20, 2024

Suzy Hansen, a journalist and author of "Notes on a Foreign Country," investigates the myth of American exceptionalism. She discusses its historical roots and how it shaped U.S. identity and foreign policy, especially after the recent election. Hansen delves into why many Americans feel disillusioned with this narrative and suggests a need for a more inclusive national identity. The conversation also touches on the European Union's strategies in response to potential U.S. tariffs and perspectives on mandatory national service.

26:47

Creator website

Episode guests

Suzy Hansen

AI Summary

AI Chapters

Episode notes

Podcast summary created with Snipd AI

Quick takeaways

American exceptionalism, historically framed as the U.S. as a beacon of virtue, is increasingly questioned due to recent foreign policy failures.

The need to redefine American identity emphasizes improving domestic conditions over the outdated belief in inherent national superiority.

Deep dives

The Origins of American Exceptionalism

American exceptionalism has deep historical roots, stretching back to the founding of the nation. It is often linked to the belief that the United States serves as a promised land, attracting immigrants who perceive it as a beacon of virtue and opportunity. This ideology has evolved over the centuries, reinforced especially after World War II, when victory cemented the idea of the U.S. as a uniquely virtuous nation. However, this belief has also formed a problematic lens through which Americans view foreign policy, leading to interventions under the assumption that the U.S. could bestow democracy and prosperity upon other nations.

Intro

2min

Rethinking American Exceptionalism

15min

Examining American Identity and Exceptionalism

7min

Political Promises vs. Market Realities

5min

Engaging Listeners and Promoting Financial Literacy

2min

Today we’re talking about American exceptionalism: the idea that the United States is a uniquely virtuous nation and a “shining city on a hill.” It’s a belief that’s long shaped how the U.S. acts on the global stage and how Americans see themselves, the economy and democracy. In the aftermath of the U.S. presidential election, many Americans are questioning the idea of exceptionalism.

Journalist Suzy Hansen challenges the notion of American exceptionalism in her book “Notes on a Foreign Country: An American Abroad in a Post-American World.” On the show today, she explains where the idea of American exceptionalism comes from, how it has shaped today’s world, and why many Americans are disillusioned with it. Plus, is a new version of national pride the answer to the pitfalls of American exceptionalism?

Then, we’ll get into the creative ways the European Union is preparing for President-elect Donald Trump’s promised tariffs. Plus, perspectives from an American abroad and thoughts on mandatory national service.

Here’s everything we talked about today: