Anya Steinberg, an associate producer at NPR, shares insights from her reporting trip to Owens Valley on the creation of the Los Angeles aqueduct. The conversation reveals the impact of the aqueduct on rural communities, particularly Indigenous rights and water management struggles. Anya explores the historical and emotional ramifications of this water infrastructure, touching on traditional irrigation practices of the Paiute and Shoshone tribes. She also raises moral questions about climate change and resource allocation, offering a rich perspective on sustainability.
The construction of the Los Angeles Aqueduct facilitated urban expansion, but prioritized L.A.'s growth over the environmental and community rights of Owens Valley residents.
Voices from Owens Valley, especially Indigenous communities, highlight ongoing struggles with water rights and environmental degradation caused by the aqueduct's operations.
Deep dives
The Significance of the L.A. Aqueduct
The construction of the Los Angeles Aqueduct was a pivotal moment in the expansion of L.A., enabling it to evolve from a small frontier town into a sprawling metropolis. The aqueduct, which transports water from Owens Valley to Los Angeles, was built to provide the essential resource needed for a growing population and urban development. This project was justified through a utilitarian perspective, weighing the needs of the many in urban L.A. against the small number of residents in Owens Valley. However, this perspective led to severe consequences for the environment and the local communities, highlighting the complex moral implications of prioritizing one region's growth over another's enduring resource rights and ecological health.
Human Voices in Historical Context
In telling the story of the aqueduct, the focus often centers on its benefits to Los Angeles, neglecting the voices of those in Owens Valley who were adversely affected. Documenting the experiences and emotions of local residents, particularly the Indigenous tribes, reveals a narrative of loss and injustice that persists today. Individuals, such as Noah Williams from the Big Pine Paiute Tribe, expressed their ongoing struggles regarding water rights and the environmental degradation caused by the aqueduct's operations. This approach emphasizes the need for a broader conversation about historical grievances and the continuing impact of decisions made over a century ago.
Reflections on Resource Allocation Ethics
The philosophical question of whether the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few emerges prominently in discussions about the L.A. Aqueduct. The episode challenges listeners to consider the ethical dimensions of resource allocation, especially concerning water scarcity in the context of climate change. Conversations with locals reveal feelings of being treated as a water colony, serving the needs of a distant city while their own environment suffers. This moral complexity encourages a deeper understanding of past decisions and points towards the pressing need for equitable resource management that respects all communities involved.
Throughline associate producer Anya Steinberg talks to supervising senior editor Julie Caine about her reporting trip to Owens Valley in northeastern California for the episode, "Water in the West," about the creation of—and controversy over—the Los Angeles aqueduct.
This normally would be a bonus episode just for Throughline+ listeners. With this being the season of giving, we're sharing this one with everyone! To access all of Throughline's bonus episodes, listen to every episode sponsor-free, and support public radio, sign up for Throughline+ at plus.npr.org/throughline