The hosts reflect on recent difficulties and tensions. They discuss the impact of recent events on diaspora Jews and the shift in conversations. The chapter analyzes the Israeli blockade and concerns about blowback on Jews. It also discusses challenges faced by diaspora Jews and the intention of Hamas. The actions of Hamas and their impact on Israelis and Jewish people are explored.
The hosts acknowledge the tension in their conversations arising from differing perspectives on Israeli government policies, highlighting the need for empathy and understanding in difficult discussions.
The hosts discuss the larger context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, reflecting on missed opportunities for peace and expressing concern for the vulnerability of future generations.
Deep dives
The Impact of Recent Events on the Podcast
The podcast hosts reflect on the recent difficult weeks and observe that there may be tension between them. They agree to address the issue and discuss their differing perspectives on the podcast. They decide to have a conversation about their personal experiences and how they view the current situation, aiming to provide insights for their listeners who may be having similar conversations. They title this experiment 'War Therapy' or 'Wartime Therapy'.
The Guilt and Observations of Diaspora Jews
One host expresses guilt as a diaspora Jew living outside Israel, feeling distant from the direct impact of the events compared to those who experienced the recent hardships. They also mention how some listeners, including a 16-year-old, have described feeling survivor's guilt. The other host acknowledges this but emphasizes that the impact is much greater within Israel. They discuss how this dynamic can create tension in their conversations and how they both feel a sense of defensiveness and attack when discussing certain topics.
Miscommunication and Misunderstandings in Conversations
The hosts talk about how their conversations have changed, with one host feeling criticized by the other when discussing Israeli government policies, while the other host feels that they are being attacked instead of just discussing the overall situation. They also mention how relaying external perspectives and media coverage can be misunderstood as personal disagreement. The hosts agree that they need to clarify their intentions when discussing different viewpoints. They recognize the need for understanding and empathy in difficult conversations.
The Larger Context and Missed Opportunities for Peace
The hosts discuss the larger context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, highlighting missed opportunities for peace. They mention the decline of secular Palestinian nationalists and the growing strength of Hamas. They reflect on past peace processes and the failure to reach a lasting agreement. One host expresses concern about the consequences of not making peace and the potential vulnerability of future generations. They both express disappointment with the current state of affairs and the impact it has on the Jewish community.
The war has been a period of grief and anxiety, but also of strain and stress felt around every Jewish table, inside Israel and out. For this special episode, exactly one month after the 7 October attacks, Yonit and Jonathan decided they should talk through some of the tensions that have surfaced in their own conversations, teasing out some of the differences between them and bringing those differences into the open. The aim was a conversation between two people - one in Israel, one in the Jewish diaspora - that would be raw and candid, true and heartfelt... but also, perhaps, a little cathartic.
--
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/unholypodcast/ Join our Facebook group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1150578065793142