Amanda Chicago Lewis, a journalist known for her insightful reporting on Chicken Soup for the Soul, delves into the brand's fascinating transformation. She reveals how a self-help series designed to uplift millions has morphed into a controversial corporate entity, dabbling in everything from packaged foods to meme stocks. They discuss the series' cultural impact during the '90s, its initial promise of personal growth, and the shift towards a more commercial focus. The conversation touches on the legacy and challenges that have defined the brand's tumultuous journey.
The Chicken Soup for the Soul brand initially thrived by merging motivational principles with relatable narratives, captivating a diverse readership for over three decades.
The shift in ownership transformed the brand from a purveyor of inspiration to a corporate entity focused on product diversification and entertainment ventures, ultimately facing financial challenges.
Deep dives
The Rise of Chicken Soup for the Soul
The Chicken Soup for the Soul brand emerged in the 1990s as a unique series of uplifting stories aimed at teenagers and young adults, encapsulating themes of resilience and personal growth. The initial success was achieved by authors Jack Canfield and Mark Victor Hansen, who saw an opportunity to combine motivational principles with compelling narratives that resonated with readers' emotions. Their strategy included selling the first book through unconventional methods, such as burgers and seminar attendees, which sparked a grassroots momentum that turned it into a bestseller. Over time, the series expanded dramatically with numerous sequels and themed editions, creating a multifaceted marketing phenomenon that became a staple in American households.
The Controversial Philosophy of Positivity
At the core of the Chicken Soup for the Soul books is a philosophy rooted in the law of attraction, suggesting that positive thinking can manifest good outcomes in life. This belief, alongside the stories included in the series, promotes a form of individualism that implies personal responsibility for both successes and failures, effectively sidestepping broader societal issues. Critics argue that the series glosses over complex realities like systemic injustice by implying anyone can overcome challenges solely through positivity and personal agency. Furthermore, this philosophy had wider cultural implications, particularly in shaping self-help narratives in the 21st century, exemplified by works like The Secret, which aligned closely with the ideologies found in Chicken Soup for the Soul.
Corporate Transformation and the Quest for New Ventures
As Chicken Soup for the Soul transitioned to new ownership in the late 2000s, the focus shifted from a self-help ethos to a corporate expansion strategy that included licensing and diversified product lines. This period saw the introduction of various consumer products and an attempt to break into the entertainment sector with TV shows and films, which aimed to leverage the brand's strong recognition. However, many of these ventures met with limited success, and the once-cuddly brand began to face criticism for its commercial approach, leading to a dilution of its original feel-good message. The shift in ownership and corporate direction marked a stark departure from its initial intent, as the brand transformed into a financial entity rather than a purveyor of comfort.
The Fall and Reckoning of a Legacy Brand
Despite initial flurries of success and even involvement in the meme stock movement with an acquisition of Redbox, Chicken Soup for the Soul Entertainment faced significant challenges in the evolving media landscape. The company's strategic decisions, particularly in the acquisition of Redbox, led to severe financial losses and a burgeoning debt crisis, ultimately culminating in its bankruptcy filing. As investors rallied around Redbox in hopes of a short squeeze reminiscent of GameStop's saga, the reality of corporate mismanagement undermined the optimism that once defined the company. Presently, the brand continues to exist, albeit in a diminished capacity, relying on nostalgia and its historical success while trying to navigate a complex and saturated market.
Chicken Soup for the Soul was the brainchild of two motivational speakers who preach the New Thought belief system known as the Law of Attraction. For more than 30 years, the self-help series has compiled reader-submitted stories about kindness, courage, and perseverance into easily digestible books aimed at almost every conceivable demographic: Chicken Soup for the Teenage Soul, Chicken Soup for the Grandma’s Soul, Chicken Soup for the Golfer’s Soul, and on and on. Since 1993, these books have sold more than 500 million copies worldwide, becoming the best-selling non-fiction book series of all time.
But in recent years, the company has become many other things that seem lightyears away from inspirational publishing: a line of packaged foods, a DVD kiosk retailer, and a meme stock. In this episode, with the help of journalist Amanda Chicago Lewis, we tell the story of how this feel-good brand went from comfort food to junk.
This episode was written by Willa Paskin and Max Freedman and produced by Max. It was edited by Evan Chung, Decoder Ring’s supervising producer. Our show is also produced by Katie Shepherd. Merritt Jacob is Senior Technical Director. Special thanks to Rachel Strom.
If you have any cultural mysteries you want us to decode, please email us at DecoderRing@slate.com, or leave a message on our hotline at 347-460-7281.
Want more Decoder Ring? Subscribe to Slate Plus to unlock exclusive bonus episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe now on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of the Decoder Ring show page. Or, visit slate.com/decoderplus to get access wherever you listen.
